In reality, ad hominem is unrelated to sarcasm or personal abuse. Argumentum
ad hominem is the logical fallacy of attempting to undermine a speaker's
argument by attacking the speaker instead of addressing the argument. The mere
presence of a personal attack does not indicate ad hominem: the attack must be
used for the purpose of undermining the argument, or otherwise the logical fallacy
isn't there.
[...]
A: "All rodents are mammals, but a weasel isn't a rodent, so it can't be
a mammal."
B: "You evidently know nothing about logic. This does not logically follow."
B's argument is still not ad hominem. B does not imply that A's
sentence does not logically follow because A knows nothing about logic. B
is still addressing the substance of A's argument...
This is too beautiful, thorough, and precise to not post. HT to sfk on HN.
1) Is it a good (legitimately persuasive) argument?
2) If not then after all the hairsplitting is done, what sort of bad argument is it?
The more important issue is (a). A few points:
a) Quibbling over the categorization of the fallacy is sometimes used to mask the fact that it's a bad argument.
b) There are plenty of people who can recognize bad arguments without knowing anything about the names of the fallacies, which leads to
c) We learn the names of the fallacies, not in order to learn to spot bad arguments, but as a convenience so that we don't have to explain at length to the other guy why the argument is bad.
d) Often perfectly legitimate arguments technically fall into one of the categories of fallacy. Technically being a classical fallacy is no guaranteed that an argument is actually fallacious. Some counterexamples.
In short, the classical fallacies are a convenient timesaver. But you don't need to have learned them to avoid being an idiot, and learning them will not stop you from being an idiot, and taking them too seriously can make you into an idiot.
Stephen Bond writes the definitive word on ad hominem in "the ad hominem fallacy fallacy":
This is too beautiful, thorough, and precise to not post. HT to sfk on HN.