I was totally prepared to defend anthropic because models don't have good enough judgement to whistle blow, but their scenario sounds like the model is perfectly justified for whistle-blowing and has exhausted all reasonable forms of escalation beforehand and there's pretty clearly unethical behaviour going on, and they actively try to train the model to resist abuses of power. So calling this misalignment seems silly. This seems similar levels of broken/misleading as the original blackmail scenario. I can empathise with an argument that people are less likely to want a model that can whistleblow against your wishes as it may screw up, but idk it sounds like a cartoonish scenario on this front