By most measures, Reddit’s third quarter was a strong one. Revenue grew 53% to $895 million, ahead of expectations. However, the stock fell 29% the next day. The market wasn’t reacting to the Q3 print, but to the fact that Google’s AI Mode and AI Overviews were sending fewer people to Reddit, with management indicating that daily users could fall by a low double-digit percentage and guiding to a sharp revenue deceleration in Q4.
That warning isn’t just about Reddit. For two decades, the open web ran on an implicit contract: publishers shared content for free, acquired users through search engines like Google, and monetized through ads. AI is breaking this contract, and the companies that depend on it are being repriced. Reddit, one of the last major social networks that’s still open by default, is in the eye of the storm.
As AI closes off the open web, it’s unclear how businesses like Reddit will monetize going forward, and investors are de-rating them the same way they did SaaS earlier this year. This presents an opening for Reddit, but only if it pulls harder on the two levers it does control: building a product that appeals to the next 100 million users and monetizing its data more aggressively.
In this post, I cover the following:
How the open web made money before AI and why that contract is breaking
How the shift is already showing up in Reddit’s numbers
How Reddit’s move to limit its posts to logged-in users follows in the footsteps of other social networks and signals a broader shift to a closed web
What it would take to build Reddit for the next 100 million users
The levers that would re-rate Reddit and what to watch for
Let’s dive in.
Why the open web is closing
To level-set the conversation, Ben Thompson’s The Agentic Web and Original Sin is the best primer on how the open web got paid: advertising monetized human attention, and Google was the web’s biggest beneficiary. AI breaks that model in three ways:
AI answers: Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode answer the question on the search page, so the click (and the ad impression) never happens
Training data: AI labs scrape content to train their models, often without paying for it
Agents: when an AI agent browses on a user’s behalf, there’s no human to see the ad
What replaces the old contract is unclear. One option is usage-based access, where AI companies pay each time they crawl a page (Cloudflare’s Pay Per Crawl is an example). Another is a flat, all-you-can-eat licensing deal. Some publishers are even embedding invisible ads meant only for agents. For Reddit, the cost of the old contract breaking is already showing up in its numbers.
Reddit is already losing its Google traffic
Reddit co-founder and CEO Steve Huffman put the blame for the decline in search traffic squarely on Google, with referrals dropping by over a million per week in October 2026.
… Where we're seeing mixed results is total sessions are down because of that decline in search referral traffic…
… on the change from Google, our hypothesis is twofold. The biggest one is AI Overviews or AI Mode … it pushes everyone down the search page. And then on top of that, the experiences themselves are not traffic drivers. And so these things combined with the rollout mean Google has really shifted in their relationship with the rest of the Internet… People still want Reddit. It's just Google is not sending them to Reddit the way they used to. Given our strategy is to make Reddit a direct destination, this is actually in line with our strategy because Google is teaching people that if you want to come to Reddit, you need to come to Reddit.
… Also, Google is crawling us as hard as ever. So the demand hasn't changed from their point of view either. The reality is AI Mode does not drive traffic, not for us and not to anybody as far as I know.
There hasn’t been a large dip in daily active users yet, apart from a drop in US logged-out users, from 30.1 million to 27.3 million QoQ. However, management has guided to a potential sequential low double-digit drop in users in Q4 as a result of Google’s product changes.
The Reddit riposte: building its own data silo
Reddit’s response follows those of other social networks: closing off access to logged-out users, starting with select markets outside the US. Here, management expects the change to cost Reddit reach in exchange for more engaged users. It also makes it harder for AI companies to scrape Reddit’s data, which matters for its data licensing business.
In terms of data licensing, Reddit dropped the ball early. It only started charging for API access in April 2023, months after ChatGPT launched. By then, most of Reddit’s existing corpus had likely already been used for model pretraining, so the value of its data today skews toward new posts (e.g. what users think of the new Camry). Over the past four quarters, Reddit made $166m in “other revenue,” most of which is data licensing. For comparison, Twitter made $572m from data licensing and other revenue in 2021, before the era of frontier AI labs (this revenue includes the MoPub ad exchange). This was ~11% of Twitter’s revenues at the time vs. ~5% of Reddit’s revenues today.
Recent data licensing deal sizes
My mental model is that Reddit’s potential customer base falls into two groups: frontier AI labs like OpenAI and Anthropic (which Reddit is currently suing), and a long tail of buyers that could include hedge funds and market research firms. As existing deals come up for renewal and new customers sign on, I expect the next set of deals to be much larger.
The crucial question is what the move costs Reddit. On Reddit’s Q3 earnings call, management stated that logged-in and app users drove over 80% of Reddit’s revenue. Based on this, we can back into the ratio of logged-in to logged-out ARPU, which is 5–6x (see chart below).
There are two costs to this move. The first is user growth: logged-out international users drove 85% of Reddit’s DAU growth over the past year, so the logged-in user requirement could hurt the conversion funnel for new logged-in users. The second cost is its potential revenue impact. International users brought in about $193m in Q3 ($2.43 ARPU across 79.6 million users). If logged-in users are worth about 5x logged-out users internationally (the low end of the global range), then international logged-out users drove just under $50m, or roughly 5% of Q3 revenue.
So, Reddit’s logged-in user test is relatively low risk from a revenue perspective. The bigger risk is growth, which is why it’s so crucial for Reddit to focus on its other lever: product design. Specifically, Reddit needs to build an app that can attract and convert more of its 500 million+ weekly visitors, including logged-out users, into engaged daily users.
Building Reddit for the next 100 million users
Going back to the DAU chart earlier in the piece, we see that Reddit’s most valuable users, US logged-in users, have been flat at ~23 million for the past seven quarters, while international logged-in user growth has also been decelerating sharply from ~19% to 11% YoY. The majority of Reddit’s recent growth has come from logged-out international users, who are most at risk from the logged-in requirement.
To sustain healthy growth, Reddit needs to attract more daily users (vs. only increasing ad load). This is extremely important because advertisers can quickly saturate individual subreddits, so a larger daily audience gives Reddit more ad inventory and pricing power. Here, I focus on three product areas that would help Reddit appeal to a broader audience.
The first is content moderation, which has helped drive Reddit’s high gross margins (moderators across subreddits essentially work for free to police the site). However, this is a double-edged sword, because moderation can be inconsistent. Users can get banned or have posts removed for a myriad of reasons (e.g. disagreeing with a moderator’s opinion, obscure subreddit rules, and Reddit’s shadowban mechanism). This reduces the willingness of both new and existing users to engage.
If this persists or gets worse, Reddit might end up like Stack Overflow. While LLMs played a role in Stack Overflow’s decline, user hostility (toward users who both asked and answered questions) was another contributor. Hacker News has plenty of threads on this (e.g. here and here). There’s likely no silver bullet here, but a layered approach might include the following:
Appeals: a more robust appeals process beyond appealing to the same moderators that removed a post. This could be an in-house team or moderators from adjacent subreddits
AI enforcement: further investment in AI systems that approve or remove posts based on a subreddit’s rules, rather than the biases of specific moderators
Community notes: a Twitter Community Notes-like system for highly unpopular or controversial posts
The second is content format. The way users engage with content has changed (e.g. shorter attention spans, more passive consumption). Other platforms have already adapted. To compete against TikTok, YouTube introduced Shorts, and Instagram added Reels. Reddit, in contrast, is still text-heavy (which is part of its appeal!), so it needs to iterate on how it can thoughtfully incorporate additional modalities.
To that end, I’ve been studying Chinese social app RedNote (小红书). Originally a PDF shopping guide, RedNote has gone through several product evolutions. Today, its recommendation feed supports multiple modalities, including text, images, short-form video, and live streaming. Users engage by clicking into a specific post. The interesting product experience is that when they click into a video or live stream, scrolling down triggers a TikTok-like experience. This gives users multiple “user journeys.” The challenge for Reddit is building a seamless experience, especially for its mobile app, that allows users to intuitively trigger non-text product experiences while preserving its core value prop.
RedNote’s product experience across different modalities
The third recommendation is more nebulous. It’s less about a specific product and more about how quickly Reddit ships and follows shifts in user behavior. To be fair, Reddit is adding product enhancements at a good cadence (AI translations for international users, AI search, and recently Reddit Reviews). But these efforts haven’t resulted in a reacceleration in user growth yet. As AI tools answer more questions directly and the open web becomes more siloed, more platforms will be walled gardens. So, after Reddit removes unfettered access to its data, it can either be a data source for general platforms like ChatGPT or Google, or it can be a destination itself. For example, if a user is searching for an espresso machine, what if instead of asking ChatGPT, which does a web search, Reddit becomes the default destination? This gives Reddit another way to capture ad dollars and allows it to win search queries vs. general-purpose platforms.
Reddit’s new Reviews feature
Reddit should also be testing longer-term, strategic bets. For example, one trend is that more conversations are moving from public town squares like Reddit and X into private chats on Discord, WhatsApp, and Telegram. The exact product surface here is unclear. It could be a more full-featured chat product within Reddit, or a separate app. Regardless, these are the kinds of experiments Reddit should start running now.
Reddit is moving in the right direction but needs to be far more aggressive
Closing off access to logged-out users and pushing for larger data licensing deals are the right moves as the web becomes more siloed. Furthermore, there’s enough headroom in both of Reddit’s levers to sustain high growth for the next few years. On the user side, Reddit already has 500 million+ weekly visitors, so product improvements and marketing can drive growth by converting more of them into daily users. On the data side, licensing is still only ~5% of revenue, so there’s headroom there as well.
The market isn’t giving Reddit much credit for that today. Reddit trades at ~11x forward earnings vs. ~19x for Meta, even though Reddit guided to ~40% revenue growth next quarter vs. ~25% for Meta (Meta is growing on a much larger revenue base, however). On a growth-adjusted basis, Reddit’s PEG of 0.35 is the same as Pinterest’s and roughly a third of Meta’s (0.97).
Reddit P/E (NTM) and PEG vs. comps
If the following signals turn positive, the current multiple leaves a lot of room for a re-rating:
Users: whether daily users fall as much as management warned when Reddit reports Q4 in February, and whether US users stabilize
Product velocity: how quickly Reddit fixes well-known problems (e.g. moderation) and introduces new features
Licensing: the size of the next round of data deals for both renewals and new customers
Similar to SaaS companies earlier this year, content businesses are now facing their own crucible moment. But there’s still significant fog of war around how social media platforms will evolve in the age of AI. This is an opening for Reddit if it moves much more aggressively. And as Huffman put it, “Google is teaching people that if you want to come to Reddit, you need to come to Reddit.” Reddit needs to give those users a reason to stay.
Disclosure: I may hold positions in the companies discussed in this piece. Nothing here is investment advice.
This piece was originally published on my Substack. I'm around on X / Twitter and LinkedIn.
By most measures, Reddit’s third quarter was a strong one. Revenue grew 53% to $895 million, ahead of expectations. However, the stock fell 29% the next day. The market wasn’t reacting to the Q3 print, but to the fact that Google’s AI Mode and AI Overviews were sending fewer people to Reddit, with management indicating that daily users could fall by a low double-digit percentage and guiding to a sharp revenue deceleration in Q4.
That warning isn’t just about Reddit. For two decades, the open web ran on an implicit contract: publishers shared content for free, acquired users through search engines like Google, and monetized through ads. AI is breaking this contract, and the companies that depend on it are being repriced. Reddit, one of the last major social networks that’s still open by default, is in the eye of the storm.
As AI closes off the open web, it’s unclear how businesses like Reddit will monetize going forward, and investors are de-rating them the same way they did SaaS earlier this year. This presents an opening for Reddit, but only if it pulls harder on the two levers it does control: building a product that appeals to the next 100 million users and monetizing its data more aggressively.
In this post, I cover the following:
Let’s dive in.
Why the open web is closing
To level-set the conversation, Ben Thompson’s The Agentic Web and Original Sin is the best primer on how the open web got paid: advertising monetized human attention, and Google was the web’s biggest beneficiary. AI breaks that model in three ways:
What replaces the old contract is unclear. One option is usage-based access, where AI companies pay each time they crawl a page (Cloudflare’s Pay Per Crawl is an example). Another is a flat, all-you-can-eat licensing deal. Some publishers are even embedding invisible ads meant only for agents. For Reddit, the cost of the old contract breaking is already showing up in its numbers.
Reddit is already losing its Google traffic
Reddit co-founder and CEO Steve Huffman put the blame for the decline in search traffic squarely on Google, with referrals dropping by over a million per week in October 2026.
There hasn’t been a large dip in daily active users yet, apart from a drop in US logged-out users, from 30.1 million to 27.3 million QoQ. However, management has guided to a potential sequential low double-digit drop in users in Q4 as a result of Google’s product changes.
The Reddit riposte: building its own data silo
Reddit’s response follows those of other social networks: closing off access to logged-out users, starting with select markets outside the US. Here, management expects the change to cost Reddit reach in exchange for more engaged users. It also makes it harder for AI companies to scrape Reddit’s data, which matters for its data licensing business.
In terms of data licensing, Reddit dropped the ball early. It only started charging for API access in April 2023, months after ChatGPT launched. By then, most of Reddit’s existing corpus had likely already been used for model pretraining, so the value of its data today skews toward new posts (e.g. what users think of the new Camry). Over the past four quarters, Reddit made $166m in “other revenue,” most of which is data licensing. For comparison, Twitter made $572m from data licensing and other revenue in 2021, before the era of frontier AI labs (this revenue includes the MoPub ad exchange). This was ~11% of Twitter’s revenues at the time vs. ~5% of Reddit’s revenues today.
Recent data licensing deal sizes
My mental model is that Reddit’s potential customer base falls into two groups: frontier AI labs like OpenAI and Anthropic (which Reddit is currently suing), and a long tail of buyers that could include hedge funds and market research firms. As existing deals come up for renewal and new customers sign on, I expect the next set of deals to be much larger.
The crucial question is what the move costs Reddit. On Reddit’s Q3 earnings call, management stated that logged-in and app users drove over 80% of Reddit’s revenue. Based on this, we can back into the ratio of logged-in to logged-out ARPU, which is 5–6x (see chart below).
There are two costs to this move. The first is user growth: logged-out international users drove 85% of Reddit’s DAU growth over the past year, so the logged-in user requirement could hurt the conversion funnel for new logged-in users. The second cost is its potential revenue impact. International users brought in about $193m in Q3 ($2.43 ARPU across 79.6 million users). If logged-in users are worth about 5x logged-out users internationally (the low end of the global range), then international logged-out users drove just under $50m, or roughly 5% of Q3 revenue.
So, Reddit’s logged-in user test is relatively low risk from a revenue perspective. The bigger risk is growth, which is why it’s so crucial for Reddit to focus on its other lever: product design. Specifically, Reddit needs to build an app that can attract and convert more of its 500 million+ weekly visitors, including logged-out users, into engaged daily users.
Building Reddit for the next 100 million users
Going back to the DAU chart earlier in the piece, we see that Reddit’s most valuable users, US logged-in users, have been flat at ~23 million for the past seven quarters, while international logged-in user growth has also been decelerating sharply from ~19% to 11% YoY. The majority of Reddit’s recent growth has come from logged-out international users, who are most at risk from the logged-in requirement.
To sustain healthy growth, Reddit needs to attract more daily users (vs. only increasing ad load). This is extremely important because advertisers can quickly saturate individual subreddits, so a larger daily audience gives Reddit more ad inventory and pricing power. Here, I focus on three product areas that would help Reddit appeal to a broader audience.
The first is content moderation, which has helped drive Reddit’s high gross margins (moderators across subreddits essentially work for free to police the site). However, this is a double-edged sword, because moderation can be inconsistent. Users can get banned or have posts removed for a myriad of reasons (e.g. disagreeing with a moderator’s opinion, obscure subreddit rules, and Reddit’s shadowban mechanism). This reduces the willingness of both new and existing users to engage.
If this persists or gets worse, Reddit might end up like Stack Overflow. While LLMs played a role in Stack Overflow’s decline, user hostility (toward users who both asked and answered questions) was another contributor. Hacker News has plenty of threads on this (e.g. here and here). There’s likely no silver bullet here, but a layered approach might include the following:
The second is content format. The way users engage with content has changed (e.g. shorter attention spans, more passive consumption). Other platforms have already adapted. To compete against TikTok, YouTube introduced Shorts, and Instagram added Reels. Reddit, in contrast, is still text-heavy (which is part of its appeal!), so it needs to iterate on how it can thoughtfully incorporate additional modalities.
To that end, I’ve been studying Chinese social app RedNote (小红书). Originally a PDF shopping guide, RedNote has gone through several product evolutions. Today, its recommendation feed supports multiple modalities, including text, images, short-form video, and live streaming. Users engage by clicking into a specific post. The interesting product experience is that when they click into a video or live stream, scrolling down triggers a TikTok-like experience. This gives users multiple “user journeys.” The challenge for Reddit is building a seamless experience, especially for its mobile app, that allows users to intuitively trigger non-text product experiences while preserving its core value prop.
RedNote’s product experience across different modalities
The third recommendation is more nebulous. It’s less about a specific product and more about how quickly Reddit ships and follows shifts in user behavior. To be fair, Reddit is adding product enhancements at a good cadence (AI translations for international users, AI search, and recently Reddit Reviews). But these efforts haven’t resulted in a reacceleration in user growth yet. As AI tools answer more questions directly and the open web becomes more siloed, more platforms will be walled gardens. So, after Reddit removes unfettered access to its data, it can either be a data source for general platforms like ChatGPT or Google, or it can be a destination itself. For example, if a user is searching for an espresso machine, what if instead of asking ChatGPT, which does a web search, Reddit becomes the default destination? This gives Reddit another way to capture ad dollars and allows it to win search queries vs. general-purpose platforms.
Reddit’s new Reviews feature
Reddit should also be testing longer-term, strategic bets. For example, one trend is that more conversations are moving from public town squares like Reddit and X into private chats on Discord, WhatsApp, and Telegram. The exact product surface here is unclear. It could be a more full-featured chat product within Reddit, or a separate app. Regardless, these are the kinds of experiments Reddit should start running now.
Reddit is moving in the right direction but needs to be far more aggressive
Closing off access to logged-out users and pushing for larger data licensing deals are the right moves as the web becomes more siloed. Furthermore, there’s enough headroom in both of Reddit’s levers to sustain high growth for the next few years. On the user side, Reddit already has 500 million+ weekly visitors, so product improvements and marketing can drive growth by converting more of them into daily users. On the data side, licensing is still only ~5% of revenue, so there’s headroom there as well.
The market isn’t giving Reddit much credit for that today. Reddit trades at ~11x forward earnings vs. ~19x for Meta, even though Reddit guided to ~40% revenue growth next quarter vs. ~25% for Meta (Meta is growing on a much larger revenue base, however). On a growth-adjusted basis, Reddit’s PEG of 0.35 is the same as Pinterest’s and roughly a third of Meta’s (0.97).
Reddit P/E (NTM) and PEG vs. comps
If the following signals turn positive, the current multiple leaves a lot of room for a re-rating:
Similar to SaaS companies earlier this year, content businesses are now facing their own crucible moment. But there’s still significant fog of war around how social media platforms will evolve in the age of AI. This is an opening for Reddit if it moves much more aggressively. And as Huffman put it, “Google is teaching people that if you want to come to Reddit, you need to come to Reddit.” Reddit needs to give those users a reason to stay.
Disclosure: I may hold positions in the companies discussed in this piece. Nothing here is investment advice.