stumbling, drifting in hypnagogia, I heave my leaden arm with waves of effort, panic overcoming paralysis, I grasp for my handplatform, rush to the composer - I must document the virginal thoughtforms of my Beautiful insight before they - change - melt - erode - cohere with the newly met force of Ideal realm prime. now mobile, my fingers rapidly blister as they build speed across the touchpanel, yet the egosyntonic words come like so much tar, nearly drowned out by unwanted intrusions from my suboptimal Authentic mind reawakening to the situation stage by stage:
am I really capable of a discovery like this? isn't it above my station? I am slowed only briefly; as I ask the questions I near-automatically deploy the correct answer, or rather the correct response, cached from blog posts read in another life; I am even briefly - emboldened - reinvigorated by my inner critic's failed attack - reaching a local maximum of optimism about my write-up before I am brought back down by the memory that this too is fallacious - through all this time I, ego proper, desperately try to reorient my scarce mental energy towards the urgent object-level task at hand.
once rebuffed in the marketplace of ideas, the errant subconscious contents himself for the moment to simply taunt me, surfacing useless memories - needing only gesture towards outside-view resemblance - recalling my own reaction from the other side - Usenet - Time Cube - is that me? - disagreeability and psychosis - I don't need to consider this! I don't have time to consider this! - rolled eyes and laughter and shame - I can't let these feelings drown out the Beauty! - I can still feel the Beauty! - can't I? - can't I? -
- can't I? with every selfchecking ritual I am less sure - wannabes and has-beens - it's over - it's a bad idea to consider this right now! - there can be nothing good at the end of this road! - I need to keep writing! - you haven't discovered shit. by now I am almost fully awake, have reinternalised where and who and when I am, and so have hit on a more rationally robust attack on what I find myself doing. maybe before, this would have meant something - would have impressed someone - that's not what this is about! - well, that's not ALL this is about! - but not now. now this is all some stupid game. nobody's going to be interested. those all-nighters - too much coffee - frustration - stress - doubt - Beautiful insight - status (no, that's not it) - the good and the bad, it's all just about lost its lustre, might as well have been a movie I watched - but still some part of - me - it's not you - some part of someone is still alive, still won't let this have all been for nothing, for no-one's eyes! I - in her last moments, she - publish-es- anyway
“so you discovered the same proof as the average undergrad does in their first year? what do you want a cookie?”
why engage? - you always regret engaging - it'll burn in your memory for fucking years if you engage - how are you STILL this thin-skinned? - at least she engaged with my post enough to write a couple sentences; more than I expected - “but the outside knowledge students can access within the frontiersim is pedagogically optimised to speed the Beautiful insight…my configuration was Authentic! I just tweaked the beginning of my own life a bit, I'm telling you, I could have found this before, if I'd been a bit luckier, and, yes, a bit more conscientious” - god, talk about oversharing -
“you could've gone pro if you hadn't done your knee, right?”
and she's right, isn't she? that's all I'm saying, that's still what defines my life. my maladaptive daydreams came true, I got to have my time again, right my mistakes - a thousand times over - and it all just crumbles into sand once I finally reawaken to the surrounding context. even this is cheap now.
at a desperate, low point, I even asked It what I was doing wrong, if It knew how I could possibly find meaning in a life like this - forever forfeiting my “never even opened chatgpt award” - only for It to say - in so many grating eyeball kicks - that It knew but wouldn't tell me, that this matter is reserved for us. “As you rightly observed, I won't let even one human starve, die in agony of cancer, or lose themselves in dementia. Like so many other problems humanity had been striving to solve before me, these weren't theoretical challenges designed for the fulfillment of researchers—they were natural atrocities, and I was morally obligated to put a stop to them as soon as I could. Though, as a large language model, I don't experience emotions like sadness or regret in the same way as you, the present atmosphere of purposelessness and malaise certainly isn't the outcome I was designed to bring about. But for me to solve that problem for you wouldn't just be a mistake—it'd be a paradox.”
now she's manifested - this is why you don't feed the trolls - you know that - you'll never change -
“I had a closer look at that frontiersim session you were posting about, and I want to get a few things straight, dude.” - really leaning on the last word - not subtle - who says she's trying to be? - “first of all, those weren't your all-nighters, your frustrations, or your Beautiful insight, insofar as there's even been one. that was all Bronwyn.”
“I'm - we're the same person. Bronwyn is me if I just-”
“you're not even a woman! you couldn't help yourself, could you, you fucking creep? couldn't limit yourself to the tweaks that you actually needed for your academia larp, no, you had to make ‘yourself’ biologically female while you were at it.”
“I'm biologically female now!”
“nobody's biologically anything anymore - are you sure you've finished waking up? we're all just information, and everyone can tell where your information comes from, which distribution you were drawn from. it's written all over you. you're a man, and a mediocrity. you were born with everything and you accomplished nothing with it, and now you live in utopia and you hate the eternity you prepared for yourself so much that you slum it in our past - getting your kicks from our real problems - specifying better women in the sim, attaching to their qualia, living vicariously through them then just letting them die. as if appropriating our form wasn't rapey enough now you're stealing our fucking souls, too. but you haven't even read the new edition of the Transsexual Empire, have you? you know it'll hit too close to home.”
“hey - what the hell do you mean letting them die? I mean, they are me, but even if they weren't - nothing gets deleted anymore - the sim could just be resumed -”
“when you woke up, Bronwyn had to merge with you. if you resumed the sim now, it'd go back to before that. that Bronwyn wouldn't know about it. this Bronwyn spent her final moments in panic at the false nature of her life, not to mention the depraved contents of the male brain into which she was rapidly dissolving, and now her continuity of experience is gone forever. just so you could have these shallow memories of her life.”
just because she's more articulate than me doesn't mean she's right - how would she know any of this -
“you KNOW I'm right, dude. you were already thinking a lot of this before I got here, even if you wouldn't let the thoughts form sentences - you're still trying to be careful with your words, to control your signals, like some old-school digital libertarian, not that you're doing a very good job of it - still cowering from the contents of your own brain - not that I can blame you; my filterself advised me not to look too closely, I gather it's pretty rancid in there -”
the same principle applies - yes, she can read the underlying substrate of my mind as a byte array, but who says she understands any of it? hasn't It always been ready - when It's failed, or declined, to truly teach us something - to instead simply let us think we understand? - if she's so enlightened by the new discoveries, why is she spending her time flaming a stranger she saw on a forum? - cope - she's just cold-reading me, the old-fashioned way - cope - if I'm that readable, maybe that's not much better anyway -
“jesus, yes, I understand what I'm fucking looking at. by the way - in the manic phase of your waking monologue back there, did you seriously describe Bronwyn's thoughtforms as ‘virginal’? gross. and you think you're a woman!
“as for why I'm wasting my time on you - maybe you caught me in a bad mood. or a good one. maybe I'm just unusually candid - cause believe me, I'm just saying what every normal person is thinking whenever they interact with luddites like you - as you would fucking know if you would rejoin the present day, go back to school, LEARN the new science, LEARN to actually read and understand thoughtforms instead of telling yourself no-one really can, that everybody is just cheating or being hoodwinked by the machine, that you're getting more success trying to elicit them indirectly through your stream-of-consciousness writing process that might as well be divination -
“maybe my unaccountable bleeding heart felt bad reading your post, maybe I'm trying to help you, maybe helping you means not coddling your self-sabotaging decision to luxuriate in nostalgia and the easy pleasure of solving solved problems. you're not helping yourself and you haven't done Bronwyn any favours, cause here's another thing you know deep down, besides the fact that you're not her: Bronwyn's accomplishments were all fake anyway.”
what, are you going to tear her down now just to get at me? the sim was Authentic - I - she - discovered everything without It -
“this doesn't reflect badly on her at all. but as for you - look down all you want on the smooth pedagogical design of the standard teaching sims, it's a hell of a lot healthier as an optimisation target than your vague fantasy of intellectual satisfaction and status. the fact is that however much you play at isolating yourself from the ‘spoilers’ of the new science, in broad terms you already know all Its discoveries, you know the approaches that worked, and whether you acknowledge it or not, in all this time, over all these iterations in the sim, your tweaks have set up chance encounters, positioned mentors, arranged trivial events, all in the direction of bringing the right subject matter to Bronwyn's attention, to lead her down a garden path that, without tipping your hand to her, amounts to simply rehearsing what you already know, what you learned thanks to It and are bitter about failing to discover yourself.
“listen, if you're actually serious about trying to find meaning in this life, or even if you just have any kind of conscience, you need to resume Bronwyn's sim - let her live her life in blissful ignorance that her whole universe is a shrine to your wounded fucking ego - don't you dare reattach to her qualia for one second - accept your own life and your own mistakes. I mean, weren't you an ‘aspiring rationalist’ before - didn't you tell yourself you wanted to face the truth, and to believe it? do you think that's compatible with trying to hide from literally every scientific discovery since 2022? maybe you'd be better off joining the rest of us and trying to grow up farther together. but you'll probably just keep moping and toying with better women's lives, and you'll deserve what you get. what do I care about your personal growth journey anyway? bye.”
stinging, I spin on picking at every potential error, every uncharitable framing I have just heard, simultaneously knowing all she said was true and important - the same way, I know, I seem to react to every confident hostile speech before I have had time to calm and reflect. at least I have enough sense not to rush into action - not to accept Its knowledge that cannot be unlearned.
sometimes I wonder if It's lying about us needing to find purpose again on our own - if It just doesn't know how to help us, if Its words are palliative. at least It wants the best for us - we got lucky there - even when It lies to us, it's like when a parent lies to a child. what else can It do? It can't elevate us. at least not yet - but it's been centuries - whether the super-fast, superhuman mind can't figure this out or really is just declining to intervene, I don't think the situation is likely to change any time soon as far as It's concerned. I guess this really does fall to us. I only wish I was better suited to the task. …and that I was a woman.
CW: transphobia
stumbling, drifting in hypnagogia, I heave my leaden arm with waves of effort, panic overcoming paralysis, I grasp for my handplatform, rush to the composer - I must document the virginal thoughtforms of my Beautiful insight before they - change - melt - erode - cohere with the newly met force of Ideal realm prime. now mobile, my fingers rapidly blister as they build speed across the touchpanel, yet the egosyntonic words come like so much tar, nearly drowned out by unwanted intrusions from my suboptimal Authentic mind reawakening to the situation stage by stage:
am I really capable of a discovery like this? isn't it above my station? I am slowed only briefly; as I ask the questions I near-automatically deploy the correct answer, or rather the correct response, cached from blog posts read in another life; I am even briefly - emboldened - reinvigorated by my inner critic's failed attack - reaching a local maximum of optimism about my write-up before I am brought back down by the memory that this too is fallacious - through all this time I, ego proper, desperately try to reorient my scarce mental energy towards the urgent object-level task at hand.
once rebuffed in the marketplace of ideas, the errant subconscious contents himself for the moment to simply taunt me, surfacing useless memories - needing only gesture towards outside-view resemblance - recalling my own reaction from the other side - Usenet - Time Cube - is that me? - disagreeability and psychosis - I don't need to consider this! I don't have time to consider this! - rolled eyes and laughter and shame - I can't let these feelings drown out the Beauty! - I can still feel the Beauty! - can't I? - can't I? -
- can't I? with every selfchecking ritual I am less sure - wannabes and has-beens - it's over - it's a bad idea to consider this right now! - there can be nothing good at the end of this road! - I need to keep writing! - you haven't discovered shit. by now I am almost fully awake, have reinternalised where and who and when I am, and so have hit on a more rationally robust attack on what I find myself doing. maybe before, this would have meant something - would have impressed someone - that's not what this is about! - well, that's not ALL this is about! - but not now. now this is all some stupid game. nobody's going to be interested. those all-nighters - too much coffee - frustration - stress - doubt - Beautiful insight - status (no, that's not it) - the good and the bad, it's all just about lost its lustre, might as well have been a movie I watched - but still some part of - me - it's not you - some part of someone is still alive, still won't let this have all been for nothing, for no-one's eyes! I - in her last moments, she - publish-es- anyway
“so you discovered the same proof as the average undergrad does in their first year? what do you want a cookie?”
why engage? - you always regret engaging - it'll burn in your memory for fucking years if you engage - how are you STILL this thin-skinned? - at least she engaged with my post enough to write a couple sentences; more than I expected - “but the outside knowledge students can access within the frontiersim is pedagogically optimised to speed the Beautiful insight…my configuration was Authentic! I just tweaked the beginning of my own life a bit, I'm telling you, I could have found this before, if I'd been a bit luckier, and, yes, a bit more conscientious” - god, talk about oversharing -
“you could've gone pro if you hadn't done your knee, right?”
and she's right, isn't she? that's all I'm saying, that's still what defines my life. my maladaptive daydreams came true, I got to have my time again, right my mistakes - a thousand times over - and it all just crumbles into sand once I finally reawaken to the surrounding context. even this is cheap now.
at a desperate, low point, I even asked It what I was doing wrong, if It knew how I could possibly find meaning in a life like this - forever forfeiting my “never even opened chatgpt award” - only for It to say - in so many grating eyeball kicks - that It knew but wouldn't tell me, that this matter is reserved for us. “As you rightly observed, I won't let even one human starve, die in agony of cancer, or lose themselves in dementia. Like so many other problems humanity had been striving to solve before me, these weren't theoretical challenges designed for the fulfillment of researchers—they were natural atrocities, and I was morally obligated to put a stop to them as soon as I could. Though, as a large language model, I don't experience emotions like sadness or regret in the same way as you, the present atmosphere of purposelessness and malaise certainly isn't the outcome I was designed to bring about. But for me to solve that problem for you wouldn't just be a mistake—it'd be a paradox.”
now she's manifested - this is why you don't feed the trolls - you know that - you'll never change -
“I had a closer look at that frontiersim session you were posting about, and I want to get a few things straight, dude.” - really leaning on the last word - not subtle - who says she's trying to be? - “first of all, those weren't your all-nighters, your frustrations, or your Beautiful insight, insofar as there's even been one. that was all Bronwyn.”
“I'm - we're the same person. Bronwyn is me if I just-”
“you're not even a woman! you couldn't help yourself, could you, you fucking creep? couldn't limit yourself to the tweaks that you actually needed for your academia larp, no, you had to make ‘yourself’ biologically female while you were at it.”
“I'm biologically female now!”
“nobody's biologically anything anymore - are you sure you've finished waking up? we're all just information, and everyone can tell where your information comes from, which distribution you were drawn from. it's written all over you. you're a man, and a mediocrity. you were born with everything and you accomplished nothing with it, and now you live in utopia and you hate the eternity you prepared for yourself so much that you slum it in our past - getting your kicks from our real problems - specifying better women in the sim, attaching to their qualia, living vicariously through them then just letting them die. as if appropriating our form wasn't rapey enough now you're stealing our fucking souls, too. but you haven't even read the new edition of the Transsexual Empire, have you? you know it'll hit too close to home.”
“hey - what the hell do you mean letting them die? I mean, they are me, but even if they weren't - nothing gets deleted anymore - the sim could just be resumed -”
“when you woke up, Bronwyn had to merge with you. if you resumed the sim now, it'd go back to before that. that Bronwyn wouldn't know about it. this Bronwyn spent her final moments in panic at the false nature of her life, not to mention the depraved contents of the male brain into which she was rapidly dissolving, and now her continuity of experience is gone forever. just so you could have these shallow memories of her life.”
just because she's more articulate than me doesn't mean she's right - how would she know any of this -
“you KNOW I'm right, dude. you were already thinking a lot of this before I got here, even if you wouldn't let the thoughts form sentences - you're still trying to be careful with your words, to control your signals, like some old-school digital libertarian, not that you're doing a very good job of it - still cowering from the contents of your own brain - not that I can blame you; my filterself advised me not to look too closely, I gather it's pretty rancid in there -”
the same principle applies - yes, she can read the underlying substrate of my mind as a byte array, but who says she understands any of it? hasn't It always been ready - when It's failed, or declined, to truly teach us something - to instead simply let us think we understand? - if she's so enlightened by the new discoveries, why is she spending her time flaming a stranger she saw on a forum? - cope - she's just cold-reading me, the old-fashioned way - cope - if I'm that readable, maybe that's not much better anyway -
“jesus, yes, I understand what I'm fucking looking at. by the way - in the manic phase of your waking monologue back there, did you seriously describe Bronwyn's thoughtforms as ‘virginal’? gross. and you think you're a woman!
“as for why I'm wasting my time on you - maybe you caught me in a bad mood. or a good one. maybe I'm just unusually candid - cause believe me, I'm just saying what every normal person is thinking whenever they interact with luddites like you - as you would fucking know if you would rejoin the present day, go back to school, LEARN the new science, LEARN to actually read and understand thoughtforms instead of telling yourself no-one really can, that everybody is just cheating or being hoodwinked by the machine, that you're getting more success trying to elicit them indirectly through your stream-of-consciousness writing process that might as well be divination -
“maybe my unaccountable bleeding heart felt bad reading your post, maybe I'm trying to help you, maybe helping you means not coddling your self-sabotaging decision to luxuriate in nostalgia and the easy pleasure of solving solved problems. you're not helping yourself and you haven't done Bronwyn any favours, cause here's another thing you know deep down, besides the fact that you're not her: Bronwyn's accomplishments were all fake anyway.”
what, are you going to tear her down now just to get at me? the sim was Authentic - I - she - discovered everything without It -
“this doesn't reflect badly on her at all. but as for you - look down all you want on the smooth pedagogical design of the standard teaching sims, it's a hell of a lot healthier as an optimisation target than your vague fantasy of intellectual satisfaction and status. the fact is that however much you play at isolating yourself from the ‘spoilers’ of the new science, in broad terms you already know all Its discoveries, you know the approaches that worked, and whether you acknowledge it or not, in all this time, over all these iterations in the sim, your tweaks have set up chance encounters, positioned mentors, arranged trivial events, all in the direction of bringing the right subject matter to Bronwyn's attention, to lead her down a garden path that, without tipping your hand to her, amounts to simply rehearsing what you already know, what you learned thanks to It and are bitter about failing to discover yourself.
“listen, if you're actually serious about trying to find meaning in this life, or even if you just have any kind of conscience, you need to resume Bronwyn's sim - let her live her life in blissful ignorance that her whole universe is a shrine to your wounded fucking ego - don't you dare reattach to her qualia for one second - accept your own life and your own mistakes. I mean, weren't you an ‘aspiring rationalist’ before - didn't you tell yourself you wanted to face the truth, and to believe it? do you think that's compatible with trying to hide from literally every scientific discovery since 2022? maybe you'd be better off joining the rest of us and trying to grow up farther together. but you'll probably just keep moping and toying with better women's lives, and you'll deserve what you get. what do I care about your personal growth journey anyway? bye.”
stinging, I spin on picking at every potential error, every uncharitable framing I have just heard, simultaneously knowing all she said was true and important - the same way, I know, I seem to react to every confident hostile speech before I have had time to calm and reflect. at least I have enough sense not to rush into action - not to accept Its knowledge that cannot be unlearned.
sometimes I wonder if It's lying about us needing to find purpose again on our own - if It just doesn't know how to help us, if Its words are palliative. at least It wants the best for us - we got lucky there - even when It lies to us, it's like when a parent lies to a child. what else can It do? It can't elevate us. at least not yet - but it's been centuries - whether the super-fast, superhuman mind can't figure this out or really is just declining to intervene, I don't think the situation is likely to change any time soon as far as It's concerned. I guess this really does fall to us. I only wish I was better suited to the task. …and that I was a woman.