I think that while the outside view arguments on why we survive AGI are defeatable, I do think they actually need to be rebutted, and the arguments are surprisingly good, and IMO this is the weakest part of LWers arguments for AGI being a big deal, at least right now.
LWers need to actually argue for why AGI will be the most important invention in history, or at least to argue that it will be a big deal rather than something that isn't a big deal.
More importantly, I kinda wish that LWers stopped applying a specialness assumption everywhere and viewing inside views as the supermajority of your evidence.
Instead, LWers need to argue for why something's special and can't be modeled by the outside view properly, and show that work.
Arguably the most important topic about which a prediction market has yet been run: Conditional on an okay outcome with AGI, how did that happen?