I think there are a lot of cohabitive games that are focused on building (i.e Minecraft is one of the most popular games of all time). The thing that feels missing to me here is... gamey-ness. I think people have "criticized" Minecraft for being unclear what the point is, and being more of a toy or sandbox than a "game."
One of the things I'm particularly interested here is games that specifically reward your choices of how to prioritize negotiation, conflict, and building, and that give you something of a measureable outcome you can improve on. Minecraft has a very vague version of this, determined entirely by what you / other-players think is cool.
There is a game that sort of does what you are looking for here: Eco. Imagine Minecraft, except: The world and resources are limited in size, players can specialize in skills and trade with each other using player-made currencies, logistics matter, and you can create a government and arbitrary laws. On top of all that, a meteor is threatening to destroy the world in 30 real-world days, unless you can progress technology enough to build lasers to shoot it down. And you need to do all that without destroying the world due to pollution and global warming.
The dynamics of the game give people different options for what kinds of goals they want to pursue. I tend to ruthlessly pursue whatever is most profitable. Most people just like getting enough resources to build neat houses and interact with the economy. Some like building a functional government, or creating infrastructure (roads, mostly). It's still basically a sandbox game, but one where it's easy to create your own varied goals and see how well you've achieved them.
It's a game that's both utterly unique and very compelling for certain kinds of people.
Yeah I’ve actually played Eco. I wasn’t sure whether to count it as cohabitive because the meteor makes it in some ways explicitly collaborative, and the semi-competitive part wasn’t that different from Minecraft’s sandbox. But I agree it’s a pretty important game to have thought about a bit if you’re exploring this space.
I quite liked @mako yass' Peacewagers/Cohabitive Games so Far. But I found myself wanting to link to this essay by Jeff Vogel, an indie game developer and blogger. I think it says something important about the constraints of how to develop Cohabitive games.
Then I thought "actually, Jeff Vogel's post here is just a great post, I wanna make a top-level linkpost."
Vogel is an indie-game developer I've been following since the 90s, and he's got a great blog that's focused in large part on how to be commercially successful as a game developer. You can have all kinds of beautiful artsy ideas as an game designer, but if you can't make something that makes enough money to pay your bills, well, then there's a limit to how many games you can make, how many people you can hire to help make them, etc.
I was excited by mako's vision of "cohabitive games from a perspective of improving society." i.e. helping people practice openended negotation, and giving coordination theorists an empirical sandbox. But I think succeeding at this requires games that are commercially successful. (i.e. if you've only made a niche product for a few atypical gamers, you probably haven't succeeded at the more ambitious goals in the Peacewagers post)
With that context, here's some quotes from Jeff Vogel's post:
...
...
...
I think there are a lot of cohabitive games that are focused on building (i.e Minecraft is one of the most popular games of all time). The thing that feels missing to me here is... gamey-ness. I think people have "criticized" Minecraft for being unclear what the point is, and being more of a toy or sandbox than a "game."
One of the things I'm particularly interested here is games that specifically reward your choices of how to prioritize negotiation, conflict, and building, and that give you something of a measureable outcome you can improve on. Minecraft has a very vague version of this, determined entirely by what you / other-players think is cool.
An issue is that I think the power-fantasy of conflict is very satisfying/primal. For any game that includes it as an option, players will tend to gravitate towards it and it'll dominate. (not quite the right anecdote, but a story comes to mind from Raph Koster has a story where they put loads of effort into an intricate ecosystem in Ultimate Online, and players didn't even notice because they just ran around killing everything)
I think the killer app for a really successful cohabitive game will be to somehow give players a power fantasy that is more compelling than pure competition, while having competition be a big enough theme of the game for it to be relevant to negotiation.