A pandemic that's substantially worse than COVID-19 is a serious
possibility. If one happens, having a good mask could save your life.
A high quality reusable mask is only $30 to
$60, and I think it's well worth it to buy one for yourself.
Worth it enough that I think you should order one now if you don't
have one already.
But if you're not convinced, let's do some rough estimation.
COVID-19 killed about 0.2% of people (20M
of 8B). The 1918 flu killed more like 2.5% (50M
of 2B). Estimating from two data points is fraught, but this gives
you perhaps a 0.02% annual chance of dying in a pandemic. Engineering
could
make this much worse, especially given progress in AI, but let's set
that aside for now to make a more conservative case.
A reusable mask ("elastomeric respirator") would be really valuable to
have, if things got really bad. Let's imagine they cut your risk of
dying by half: the rated efficacy is much
higher (99%+) but real-world use isn't perfect, especially over
the months or years another pandemic could last.
A mask should last at least ten years if unused, and over that decade
it would drop this conservative estimate of your risk of
pandemic-induced death from 0.2% to 0.1%. If you, as the US
DoT does, value not dying at $14M, then this is worth $14k. Even
if the benefit of a mask is 100x lower than we estimated ($140), it's
still worth it to buy one.
I like geeking out over masks and there are a lot of
options. I have a bunch of models, and if you'd like to come try
them sometime (next EA Boston
meetup on 10/26?) I'd be happy to show you what they're like. But if
you just want to pick one and be done with it, leaving it in a box
that you more likely than not don't need to open, a time tested but
somewhat garish option is the 3M 6200 mask in Small ($17), Medium ($15), Large ($19) plus a
set of 3M
2091 p100 filters ($7/pair):
I'd also recommend buying one now instead of trying to notice when a
pandemic is coming: buying now ensures you get one instead of
scrambling when everyone else is competing over a supply that can't
keep up, and everyone who prepares ahead of time
helps reduce
shortages when a disaster comes.
Yes. On the other hand they have less condensation, are easier to breathe in, and are generally much easier to find in higher protection factors (I'm not aware of any valveless 99%+ efficacy masks)
1David Feuer
N95 is generally considered adequate for infection control. N99 is more for industrial applications, as I understand it, and is typically harder to breathe through.
It's just a matter of probabilities. Compare a well-sealed N95 vs P100 performing to spec, and the latter will filter more. In an environment where out of 100 people one would get sick with a P100, perhaps 5 would get sick with an N95.
(In real-world usage, especially among non-experts, though, there's typically some leakage around the edge of the mask, which reduces the difference between them)
A pandemic that's substantially worse than COVID-19 is a serious possibility. If one happens, having a good mask could save your life. A high quality reusable mask is only $30 to $60, and I think it's well worth it to buy one for yourself. Worth it enough that I think you should order one now if you don't have one already.
But if you're not convinced, let's do some rough estimation.
COVID-19 killed about 0.2% of people (20M of 8B). The 1918 flu killed more like 2.5% (50M of 2B). Estimating from two data points is fraught, but this gives you perhaps a 0.02% annual chance of dying in a pandemic. Engineering could make this much worse, especially given progress in AI, but let's set that aside for now to make a more conservative case.
A reusable mask ("elastomeric respirator") would be really valuable to have, if things got really bad. Let's imagine they cut your risk of dying by half: the rated efficacy is much higher (99%+) but real-world use isn't perfect, especially over the months or years another pandemic could last.
A mask should last at least ten years if unused, and over that decade it would drop this conservative estimate of your risk of pandemic-induced death from 0.2% to 0.1%. If you, as the US DoT does, value not dying at $14M, then this is worth $14k. Even if the benefit of a mask is 100x lower than we estimated ($140), it's still worth it to buy one.
I like geeking out over masks and there are a lot of options. I have a bunch of models, and if you'd like to come try them sometime (next EA Boston meetup on 10/26?) I'd be happy to show you what they're like. But if you just want to pick one and be done with it, leaving it in a box that you more likely than not don't need to open, a time tested but somewhat garish option is the 3M 6200 mask in Small ($17), Medium ($15), Large ($19) plus a set of 3M 2091 p100 filters ($7/pair):
I'd also recommend buying one now instead of trying to notice when a pandemic is coming: buying now ensures you get one instead of scrambling when everyone else is competing over a supply that can't keep up, and everyone who prepares ahead of time helps reduce shortages when a disaster comes.