I want to make a hopefully-sandboxed comment:
This seems kind of cringe.
I don't think of myself as someone who thinks in terms of cringe, much, but apparently I have this reaction. I don't particularly endorse it, or any implications of it, but it's there. Maybe it means I have some intuition that the thing is bad to do, or maybe it means I expect it to have some weird unexpected social effect. Maybe it will be mocked in a way that shows that it's not actually a good symbolic social move. Maybe the intuition is something like: protests are the sort of thing that the weak side does, the side that will be mainly ignored, or perhaps mocked, and so making a protest puts stop-AI-ists in a weak social position. (I continue to not endorse any direct implication here, such as "this is bad to do for this reason".) Why would someone in power and reasoning in terms of power, like Lecun, take the stop-AI-ists seriously, when they've basically publicly admitted to not having social power, i.e. to being losers? Someone in power can't gain more power by cooperating with losers, and does not need to heed the demands of losers because they can't threaten them in the arena of power. (I do endorse trying to be aware of this sort of dynamic. I hope to see some version of the protest that is good, and/or some version of updating on the results or non-results.)
[ETA: and to be extra clear, I definitely don't endorse making decisions from within the frame of social symbolic moves and power dynamics and conflict. That sort of situation is something that we are to some extent always in, and sometimes forced to be in and sometimes want to be in, but that thinking-frame is never something that we are forced to or should want to restrict our thinking to.]
Particularly in the rationalist community it seems like protesting is seen as a very outgroup thing to do. But why should that be? Good on you for expanding your comfort zone-- hope to see you there :)
Meta’s frontier AI models are fundamentally unsafe. Since Meta AI has released the model weights publicly, any safety measures can be removed. Before it releases even more advanced models – which will have more dangerous capabilities – we call on Meta to take responsible release seriously and stop irreversible proliferation. Join us for a peaceful protest at Meta’s office in San Francisco at 250 Howard St at 4pm PT.
RSVP on Facebook[1] or through this form.
Let’s send a message to Meta:
All you need to bring is yourself and a sign, if you want to make your own. I will lead a trip to SF from Berkeley but anyone can join at the location. We will have a sign-making party before the demonstration-- stay tuned for details. We'll go out for drinks afterward
I like the irony.