LESSWRONG
LW

Practical Guide to Anthropics
AnthropicsSleeping Beauty Paradox
Frontpage

17

Anthropic decision theory for self-locating beliefs

by Stuart_Armstrong
12th Jul 2021
AI Alignment Forum
1 min read
2

17

Ω 11

AnthropicsSleeping Beauty Paradox
Frontpage

17

Ω 11

Next:
Anthropics: different probabilities, different questions
10 comments25 karma
Log in to save where you left off
Anthropic decision theory for self-locating beliefs
5JBlack
2Stuart_Armstrong
New Comment
2 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 1:45 PM
[-]JBlack4y50

I'm not sure about the utility of a monetary payout in this variant of the Sleeping Beauty problem where she is killed at the end of the experiment. Is she assumed to pay for something she values in the one remaining day in which she (physically or psychologically) exists?

I can see two distinct possibilities here: whether she buys something of local utility (maybe an ice-cream), or of global utility (e.g. gifting it to someone she values). This may matter a great deal in the Tails case: even the copy altruistic average utilitarian will recognise that average utility is increased twice as much as in Heads for this case, even though each copy won't know whether or not it has.

Reply
[-]Stuart_Armstrong4y20

Yep.

Reply
Moderation Log
Curated and popular this week
2Comments

This is a link post to the "Anthropic decision theory for self-locating beliefs" paper, with the abstract:

This paper sets out to resolve how agents ought to act in the Sleeping Beauty problem and various related anthropic (self-locating belief) problems, not through the calculation of anthropic probabilities, but through finding the correct decision to make. It creates an anthropic decision theory (ADT) that decides these problems from a small set of principles. By doing so, it demonstrates that the attitude of agents with regards to each other (selfish or altruistic) changes the decisions they reach, and that it is very important to take this into account. To illustrate ADT, it is then applied to two major anthropic problems and paradoxes, the Presumptuous Philosopher and Doomsday problems, thus resolving some issues about the probability of human extinction.

The key points of that paper are also available in this post sequence.