I'd argue for many people, losing an hour and gaining a story even has positive utility! I'm reminded of God Mode is Boring: Musings on Interestingness, comparing The Pod of n monks in perfect meditation to Galactic Westeros, a universe of conflict: love, war, art, community, and collective struggle.
Of course there's still harm in the hour stop. It took away rider's agency for an hour. That either intrinsically sucks, or it sucks because over so many people, it's plausible a few very high-utility events were delayed or even prevented. Still, that's pretty ... (read more)
This is clearly the same Scott Alexander (as Astral Codex Ten / Star Slate Codex / @Scott Alexander ). The writing voice is distinctly his, plus he directly says in the post "In March, I wrote a snarky post called Every Debate On Pausing AI."
Not sure why there's two accounts.
I asked the AI superforecaster to predict the effect of the US passing the Sanders/Casar bill today on the likelihood of China agreeing to a pause in the next year. It said it would increase it from 1% to 7%.[15]
Don't these numbers undercut the point of this section, which is saying passing this kind of unilateral disarmament makes it harder to get China to pause? Am I reading this backwards?
FWIW I think I agree with both the prediction direction (china pause is more likely if US passes pause bill) and the overall point (US pause bill is a bad negotiation ... (read more)
I presented a version of this argument to Sean Carroll (prominent physicist/blogger) in his December 2022 AMA (for context, the past hypothesis is just the quantitative way to state the assumption that the universe began low entropy, thus throwing out all universes that emerged randomly from fluctuations and predict Boltzman brains):
Q: In the October AMA, you said there was “No experiment you can do” to prove the past hypothesis. However, it seems any universe where the laws of thermodynamics are true and the past hypothesis is false should makes some very... (read more)
Wonderful. Currently enjoying singing this to the Pokemon Theme.
I think it's fine (and laudable) to question your epistemic status here, but I'm so struck by the bystander whose epistemic status was "Something chaotic is happening on the train, someone near the action points directly to me and says 'you, the brake!'", who then didn't pull the brake. Human nature sure has breadth.