LESSWRONG
LW

307
Sam Enright
3401120
Message
Dialogue
Subscribe

Posts

Sorted by New

Wikitag Contributions

Comments

Sorted by
Newest
No wikitag contributions to display.
The Cabinet of Wikipedian Curiosities
Sam Enright3y10

Fair enough. I have removed that part of the post. 

Reply
The Cabinet of Wikipedian Curiosities
Sam Enright3y10

"Percentage of marriages that end in divorce" is an underspecified concept. There is only "percentage of marriages that end in divorce after n years". 

According to this NYT article, it is incredibly common to report (new divorces / new marriages) as the "% of marriages ending in divorce" – and this is misleading because it makes a decline in marriages look like an increase in the probability of divorce. The very large figures, like 50% or above, seem to be indeed reporting this figure. 

You could adjust for changing demographics of course, but one would think that introduces some uncertainty into the measurement.

I phrased my comment clumsily as a reason to link to something that would clarify the underspecified comment of a "divorce rate". It seems like 40% is a realistic figure for some countries after you do demographic adjustment, but, insofar as a higher figure is reported, it is because of a misunderstanding. 

I will think of a way to clarify this claim, or delete it entirely.

Reply
36The Cabinet of Wikipedian Curiosities
3y
5
13The Three Little Piggies of Rationality
4y
2
93Bryan Caplan meets Socrates
4y
7
65Before Colour TV, People Dreamed in Black and White
4y
26
24Disambiguating the ‘Observable Universe’
4y
5
10For and Against Lotteries in Elite University Admissions
4y
2
26Book Review: Open Borders
4y
19
18Questions about YIMBY
4y
2
33A Layman’s Guide to Recreational Mathematics Videos
4y
5
39Book Review: The Beginning of Infinity
4y
16
Load More