LESSWRONG
LW

Zack Friedman
22320
Message
Dialogue
Subscribe

Posts

Sorted by New

Wikitag Contributions

Comments

Sorted by
Newest
No wikitag contributions to display.
Does there exist an interactive reasoning map tool that lets users visually lay out claims, assign probabilities and confidence levels, and dynamically adjust their beliefs based on weighted influences between connected assertions?
Zack Friedman4mo40

Adele, that's awesome. I'll definitely use it next time I need Bayes-level precision.

I've been working on this quite a bit. It's only Bayes-lite though: it blends beliefs using weighted averages in log-odds space and outputs the robustness and probability of the recalculated beliefs. That should be fine for my purposes and for layman use. 

I've got the rawest of functional prototypes. But the hard part is done - the math checks out. It even propagates complex loops without breaking. It will take me a while to develop the UI though. Here's a screen grab. Not too pretty yet. I'll let you know when I really have something worth sharing.

Reply
Does there exist an interactive reasoning map tool that lets users visually lay out claims, assign probabilities and confidence levels, and dynamically adjust their beliefs based on weighted influences between connected assertions?
Zack Friedman4mo10

Thanks, I'll keep digging. You've already helped just by suggesting better search terms (e.g. “mind-mapping software").

That said, I’d still be surprised if someone hasn’t already built something close to this.

Slight tangent: About 15 years ago, I had what I thought was a novel app idea: an audio recorder that constantly buffers the last 60 seconds of sound, so if someone said something important, you could hit a button and retroactively capture it. I looked it up, and sure enough, it existed: fully developed but mostly abandoned. Same thing happened when I imagined vending machines at public tennis courts that dispense fresh tennis balls. Already patented, blueprint and all. I decided we'd reached the IP singularity (15 years ago!): naming is almost equivalent to invoking.

So unless my idea is downright incoherent or useless, I have to assume it’s already out there somewhere buried under the right search terms.

Reply
7A Practical Tool for Mapping and Quantifying Belief Networks
24d
0
11Best way to ask laypeople for conditional probabilities in a Bayes net?
Q
2mo
Q
1
5Does there exist an interactive reasoning map tool that lets users visually lay out claims, assign probabilities and confidence levels, and dynamically adjust their beliefs based on weighted influences between connected assertions?
Q
4mo
Q
4