The Shops at Waterloo Town Square - we will congregate in the indoor seating area next to the Your Independent Grocer with the trees sticking out in the middle of the benches (pic) at 7:00 pm for 20 minutes before walking back to Kaleb’s house.
Activity
This week we’ll be learning about different education systems used around the world, as well as discussing their strengths and weaknesses compared to our own. We will also discuss the state of education in general, how worried we should be about declining scores globally, and what we can do about it.
Each person should pick two or more systems to read about. Claim them in the Discord, or roll a d12 to pick. Read at least the first short article, and optionally the longer ones
National systems
Finland. No standardized tests until 18, school from age 7, little homework, highly trusted teachers. The model the world copied, now below Canada in math. Short · Longer
Singapore. A national exam at age 12 steers secondary placement, and meritocracy is state ideology. First or second in every PISA 2025 subject. Short · Longer
Germany and Switzerland. Teenagers apprentice at real companies for pay while attending vocational school. Germany sorts children at about 10, Switzerland at about 15. Short · Longer
Japan. Two systems in one: primary schools where children clean the building and serve each other lunch, then entrance exams and cram schools from junior high. Short · Longer
The Netherlands. Equal public funding for any school parents found, whether Catholic, Islamic, Montessori or Steiner, plus sorting into three streams at about 12. Short · Longer
Escuela Nueva (Colombia). One teacher, every grade in one room, children working through self-paced guides and helping each other, for about $30 extra per student a year. Short · Longer
School models
Montessori. Mixed-age classrooms, child-chosen work with purpose-built materials, long uninterrupted work periods, no rewards or punishments. Short · Longer
Unschooling. No curriculum, and no lessons unless the child asks for them: children at home follow their own interests while parents supply books, answers and opportunities. The longer reading is by David Friedman, who raised his own children this way. Short · Longer
Sudbury schools. A school with no curriculum, classes or grades, run as a direct democracy: students from age 4 and staff each get one vote on the rules, on discipline, and on which staff are rehired. Short · Longer
Alpha School. Core academics in about two hours a day on adaptive software, "guides" in place of teachers, rewards for performance. Expanding fast, with poor 2026 results in public charter schools. Short · Longer
Historical
The Chinese imperial examination. For about 1,300 years one exam, open in principle to almost any man, decided who governed China. It was abolished in 1905, and today's university entrance exam, the gaokao, is often called its heir. Short · Longer
The Spartan agoge. From age seven, citizen boys left home to be raised by the state in age groups, and were trained in endurance, obedience and fighting until about thirty. Completing it was a condition of citizenship. Short · Longer
Discussion questions
The first part of the meetup will consist of short summaries of each system by those who read them.
Which of these systems would you have thrived in as a kid, and which would have been worst for you? Is the answer the same for the median kid?
School does several jobs at once: teaching, childcare, sorting, socialization, making citizens. Which job is each system we heard about really built for? Which is ours built for?
Where and when in your life did you learn the most? Which of tonight's systems did that most resemble?
Most systems sorts children eventually: at 10 in Germany, 12 in Singapore and the Netherlands, 15 in Switzerland, 18 in Finland. When would you sort, and by exam, teacher judgement or parental choice?
Scores fell in most countries at once. If nearly every system is declining together, how much of what we call system quality is really something outside school?
Is boredom in school a cost to be removed or a skill being taught?
Is an unhappy, high-scoring childhood a reasonable price for a prosperous adulthood?
Do children need to be made to learn things they would not choose? Which things?
Finland was copied for twenty years and then fell further than almost anyone. How much should that lower our trust in “look what the top country does”?
How do you think AI will change how we do education? Do you think the overall effect will be positive or negative?
The Shops at Waterloo Town Square - we will congregate in the indoor seating area next to the Your Independent Grocer with the trees sticking out in the middle of the benches (pic) at 7:00 pm for 20 minutes before walking back to Kaleb’s house.
Activity
This week we’ll be learning about different education systems used around the world, as well as discussing their strengths and weaknesses compared to our own. We will also discuss the state of education in general, how worried we should be about declining scores globally, and what we can do about it.
We will be doing this partitioned book club style.
Readings
Optional: Your Review: School
Partitions
Each person should pick two or more systems to read about. Claim them in the Discord, or roll a d12 to pick. Read at least the first short article, and optionally the longer ones
National systems
School models
Historical
Discussion questions
The first part of the meetup will consist of short summaries of each system by those who read them.
Posted on: