Let's assume there is no such thing as true randomness. If this is true, and we create a superintelligent system which knows the location and properties of every particle in the universe, could we determine if we are in a simulation? (EDIT: to avoid running afoul of the impossibility of storing a complete description of the universe within the universe as @Karl Krueger pointed out, assume this includes approximations and is not exact). If we could, could we escape? If we could escape, is that still possible if there is such a thing as true randomness?
I am especially interested in answers to the final question.
A well-designed simulation is inescapable. Suppose that you are inside Conway's game of life, and you know that fact for sure. How specifically are you going to use this knowledge to escape, if all you are is a set of squares on a simulated grid, and all that ever happens in your universe is that some squares are flipped from black to white and vice versa?
To answer your first question, some kinds of pseudo-randomness are virtually indistinguishable from actual randomness, if you do not have a perfect knowledge of the entire universe. For example, in crypto... (read more)
1. I am saying that if there is no true randomness, then the universe could be seen as a predictable program. If we are in a simulation seemingly random events are the output of a pseudorandom random number generator. If there is true randomness a superintelligent machine can't perfectly predict the future and test the limits of the universe to determine if it is simulated.
2. Perhaps 100% understanding of the universe is not needed to escape. This is an intriguing point. It does seem to me most possibilities for escape require detection.
2papetoast
1.
[...]
The existence of true randomness eliminates some ways of detection of simulation, but not all of them. A simple example is detecting a bug in the simulation, which in theory doesn't need to depend on randomness at all.
2.
[...]
It does seem to me that way too, but I think detection alone is very insufficient for escape, such that "If we could, could we escape?" isn't that meaningful of a question. You probably need to discuss with many additional assumptions to have an answer.