This is a special post for quick takes by AMCAM. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Would trying to coordinate a boycott of Anthropic/OpenAI/the foundation labs be helpful?
1. Would it be directly effective in slowing them down? 2. Would it have beneficial secondary effects? 3. Would it have harmful secondary effects?
On 1: Effectiveness would depend on what percentage of their users actually boycotted. One option would be to have a boycott for some period of time as a way of showing concern.
On 2: I'm concerned that people have little they can do to try to slow or have any impact on RSI/Race/ASI risk. Actions and beliefs play back on each other, if people can do nothing they convince themselves they don't care. If they do something for a cause, they then believe in the cause MORE than before.
On 3: Pushing for something that then almost no-one does would send a signal of being fringe and decrease perceived social proof of significance.
I'm sure there are many other considerations here. But I'm curious if anyone has thoughts on the idea of a boycott, including what would need to be true for it to be helpful and how likely you think a boycott would be to make some defined difference.