This is a special post for quick takes by bgaesop. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
So, shouldn't all the rats who've been so into meditation etc for the past decade or so be kinda panicking at the apparent fact that enlightenment is just dunning-krugering yourself into not being able to notice your own incompetence?
I am currently very skeptical that the PNSE paper has anything of worth, given that Jeffery Martin's Finder's Course is basically a scam according to this review and some others. (I don't know if the paper is based on Finder's Course participants.) It would be valuable for someone to do a fact check on the paper.
8Raemon
My sense of what the person-at-the-reunion was talking about (having chatted with them a bit, although not sure I understand their position well enough to speak for them) was a model where Chakras roughly correspond to "application of Gendlin's Focusing, directed to particular areas of the body, turns out to yield different information."
i.e. a thing that I've heard reported by several LessWrongers is that focusing directed at your stomach tends to give a set of information about what your subconscious is thinking/feeling/interested-in, than focusing other areas of your body, or without any directed attention at all.
I've heard a couple people make the broader, somewhat stronger claim that each of the body-areas associated with a chakra tend to have consistent effects across people when used as introspection targets.
This doesn't seem particularly mysterious to me, although it seems reasonable to be escalatingly skeptical of:
* "introspecting with a focus on particular body parts yields different information about what's going on with you subconsciously than generic introspection"
* "one particular body part tends to be particular useful for this"
* "seven body parts tend to be particularly useful for this in a way that corresponds to traditional chakras, and there's a model of how those areas relate with particular introspective techniques that tend to cause particular effects, across people"