This is a special post for quick takes by etirabys. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
I've been wondering how much contraception introduces genetic selection against child abuse tendencies. My tentative belief is "a lot, and so a huge source of suffering is diminishing for future humans". Big if true.
My guess is that child abuse is disproportionately done by people who did not actively prefer to have the child (at all, or at a particular time in their life). Historically there was little selection for the trait of actively wanting children and being interested in their interiority. Now, because having children loads so much on whether it will feel fulfilling to the parent as an individual, and because the standards for the quality of the parent-child relationship are so high, there's probably a lot of selection for this.
In the past, it wasn't about an indifference or unavailability of protection, but economic considerations that children could be put to work which may have lead to a deliberate decision to have larger families (which is not necessarily at odds for "wanting children"). Or as these researchers put it:
Children were very profitable assets since their pay was very low, were less likely to strike, and were easy to be manipulated...Children from poor families were expected to participate to the family income, and sometimes they worked in dangerous conditions in 1... (read more)