I use a lot of emphasis in this comment; I want it to be clear that I am not angry---I am on the verge of despair. I am trying to understand how I can actually achieve something with my life after years of repeated failure, and your advice has not helped me in that endeavor, either because I don't understand it, or because it simply doesn't work.
This comment is not a rant. This comment is a desperate cry for help.
It has been 14 years since I wrote that post. I still haven't published that book.
By my own rights, I failed. Catastrophically. Years of my life have been wasted. For nothing.
Should I be redefining my goals to say that I succeeded anyway? That's just painting my targets after I shot my arrows. That goes against everything rationalism stands for.
We seem to have radically different notions of what GOALS are. I actually want to DO things. I want things to HAPPEN. I want that book to published so people can read it (and so that I can make money by selling it to them). That's not "too broadly formulated". That's WHAT I ACTUALLY WANT. If I could have that now, today, with no other steps, I would not be sad that I did not get to do the other steps, because that is the thing---the ONLY thing---I actually wanted.
Sure, I could set subgoals like "submit this many query letters"; and I did that, for awhile. Then the rejections wore me down until I couldn't take it anymore and I had to stop. And like I said, those subgoals never felt like I was actually accomplishing anything, because when it was all said and done I was no closer to THE OUTCOME I ACTUALLY WANTED. I DID the subgoals, for awhile at least. They weren't too much to do. The problem was that they never actually accomplished what I wanted. And you're telling me I should have set LESSER goals? Goals that would have felt even LESS like accomplishing something? How is THAT supposed to help me?
"If at all possible don't use external markers for your goals." Almost everything that I care about in life depends upon external markers. I don't want to submit job applications; I want to get a job. (Actually, I want money. If someone handed me $5 million, I would stop looking for jobs. I don't give a fuck about contributing my labor and expertise to a capitalist economy that would be post-scarcity already if it weren't ruled by psychopaths.) I don't want to write query letters; I want to publish a book. Even taking care of my mother and my husband is only worth doing if it actually helps them---going through the right motions is not actually helping if it doesn't actually help.
What does it even MEAN to have goals that don't depend on external markers? Am I supposed to "collect rejections", like some people say works for them, pretending that rejections are good now? But if I wanted 100 rejections, I could get them all tomorrow (or as soon as they decide to reply) by submitting worthless crap to 100 places that are obviously unsuited. No, in order to get what I actually want, I have to submit GOOD applications, and what it means for an application to be good is precisely that it increases my odds of achieving my actual goal of getting hired or getting published. I just don't even see how I'm supposed to make sense of the rationality of my actions at all EXCEPT by linking them to achieving this external outcome that I keep failing to achieve. This isn't FUN. I'm not LEARNING. This isn't IMPROVING me in any meaningful way. It's just this thing I have to keep doing, over and over, no matter how much it destroys my mental health, because we're not allowed to live comfortably in this society unless we fulfill the ritual correctly enough times that a capital owner decides we would be sufficiently profitable and deigns to offer us an employment contract.
" "Focus more on the trajectory than on the goal itself." Once you get there, you will want different things and what you have learned and acquired will just be normal."
BUT I DIDN'T GET THERE! I'M NOT SURE I'LL EVER GET THERE! THAT'S THE WHOLE POINT! I focused on the trajectory as hard as I could, but it was never enough to keep me motivated, and I burned myself out until I couldn't even try anymore.
Please, tell me: If you were trying to get a job or publish a book, what goals would YOU set that fit your guidelines? Because I don't see how that makes any sense at all.
In Orthodox Judaism there is a saying: “The previous generation is to the next one as angels are to men; the next generation is to the previous one as donkeys are to men.” This follows from the Orthodox Jewish belief that all Judaic law was given to Moses by God at Mount Sinai. After all, it’s not as if you could do an experiment to gain new halachic knowledge; the only way you can know is if someone tells you (who heard it from someone else, who heard it from God). Since there is no new source of information; it can only be degraded in transmission from generation to generation.
Thus, modern rabbis are not allowed to overrule ancient rabbis. Crawly things are ordinarily unkosher, but it is permissible to eat a worm found in an apple—the ancient rabbis believed the worm was spontaneously generated inside the apple, and therefore was part of the apple. A modern rabbi cannot say, “Yeah, well, the ancient rabbis knew diddly-squat about biology. Overruled!” A modern rabbi cannot possibly know a halachic principle the ancient rabbis did not, because how could the ancient rabbis have passed down the answer from Mount Sinai to him? Knowledge derives from authority, and therefore is only ever lost, not gained, as time passes.
When I was first exposed to the angels-and-donkeys proverb in (religious) elementary school, I was not old enough to be a full-blown atheist, but I still thought to myself: “Torah loses knowledge in every generation. Science gains knowledge with every generation. No matter where they started out, sooner or later science must surpass Torah.”
The most important thing is that there should be progress. So long as you keep moving forward you will reach your destination; but if you stop moving you will never reach it.
Tsuyoku naritai is Japanese. Tsuyoku is “strong”; naru is “becoming,” and the form naritai is “want to become.” Together it means, “I want to become stronger,” and it expresses a sentiment embodied more intensely in Japanese works than in any Western literature I’ve read. You might say it when expressing your determination to become a professional Go player—or after you lose an important match, but you haven’t given up—or after you win an important match, but you’re not a ninth-dan player yet—or after you’ve become the greatest Go player of all time, but you still think you can do better. That is tsuyoku naritai, the will to transcendence.
Each year on Yom Kippur, an Orthodox Jew recites a litany which begins Ashamnu, bagadnu, gazalnu, dibarnu dofi, and goes on through the entire Hebrew alphabet: We have acted shamefully, we have betrayed, we have stolen, we have slandered . . .
As you pronounce each word, you strike yourself over the heart in penitence. There’s no exemption whereby, if you manage to go without stealing all year long, you can skip the word gazalnu and strike yourself one less time. That would violate the community spirit of Yom Kippur, which is about confessing sins—not avoiding sins so that you have less to confess.
By the same token, the Ashamnu does not end, “But that was this year, and next year I will do better.”
The Ashamnu bears a remarkable resemblance to the notion that the way of rationality is to beat your fist against your heart and say, “We are all biased, we are all irrational, we are not fully informed, we are overconfident, we are poorly calibrated . . .”
Fine. Now tell me how you plan to become less biased, less irrational, more informed, less overconfident, better calibrated.
There is an old Jewish joke: During Yom Kippur, the rabbi is seized by a sudden wave of guilt, and prostrates himself and cries, “God, I am nothing before you!” The cantor is likewise seized by guilt, and cries, “God, I am nothing before you!” Seeing this, the janitor at the back of the synagogue prostrates himself and cries, “God, I am nothing before you!” And the rabbi nudges the cantor and whispers, “Look who thinks he’s nothing.”
Take no pride in your confession that you too are biased; do not glory in your self-awareness of your flaws. This is akin to the principle of not taking pride in confessing your ignorance; for if your ignorance is a source of pride to you, you may become loath to relinquish your ignorance when evidence comes knocking. Likewise with our flaws—we should not gloat over how self-aware we are for confessing them; the occasion for rejoicing is when we have a little less to confess.
Otherwise, when the one comes to us with a plan for correcting the bias, we will snarl, “Do you think to set yourself above us?” We will shake our heads sadly and say, “You must not be very self-aware.”
Never confess to me that you are just as flawed as I am unless you can tell me what you plan to do about it. Afterward you will still have plenty of flaws left, but that’s not the point; the important thing is to do better, to keep moving ahead, to take one more step forward. Tsuyoku naritai!