LESSWRONG
LW

Transhumanism
Personal Blog

4

[Video Link] PostHuman: An Introduction to Transhumanism

by Joshua_Blaine
15th Nov 2013
1 min read
12

4

Transhumanism
Personal Blog

4

[Video Link] PostHuman: An Introduction to Transhumanism
8knb
8Mestroyer
4timtyler
2Joshua_Blaine
0somervta
-6[anonymous]
1knb
5davidpearce
0somervta
0knb
0ChristianKl
0somervta
New Comment
12 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 7:16 PM
[-]knb12y80

It's a really well-made video. However, they make the claim that the doubling period for Moore's Law is shrinking, which I think is false.

Reply
[-]Mestroyer12y80

I also don't like that argument (even when presented correctly) because it ignores software and assumes you can brute-force everything.

Reply
[-]timtyler12y40

Shane Legg prepared this graph.

It was enough to convince him that there was some super-exponential synergy:

Reply
[-]Joshua_Blaine12y20

I dont disagree with the idea of an A.I. Intelligence explosion, but I do think their argument is the wrong one. It is a fairly common idea though, especially from semi-laypeople, so I'm not surprised to have seen it in their video.

Everything else in the video seemed roughly accurate, though.

Reply
[-]somervta12y00

I'm pretty sure that was Kurzweil's claim originally. Can't remember if they attribute it to him in the video or make it themselves, though.

Reply
[+][anonymous]12y-60
[-]knb12y10

I also wonder if the extreme "abolitionist" position (with regard to suffering) should be listed along anti-aging and intelligence enhancement. Abolitionism seems like it might be off-putting even to people who might support the first two planks.

Reply
[-]davidpearce12y50

"Health is a state of complete [sic] physical, mental and social well-being": the World Health Organization definition of health. Knb, I don't doubt that sometimes you're right. But Is phasing out the biology of involuntary suffering really too "extreme" - any more than radical life-extension or radical intelligence-amplification? When talking to anyone new to transhumanism, I try also to make the most compelling case I can for radical superlongevity and extreme superintelligence - biological, Kurzweilian and MIRI conceptions alike. Yet for a large minority of people - stretching from Buddhists to wholly secular victims of chronic depression and chronic pain disorders - dealing with suffering in one guise or another is the central issue. Recall how for hundreds of millions of people in the world today, time hangs heavy - and the prospect of intelligence-amplification without improved subjective well-being leaves them cold. So your worry cuts both ways.

Anyhow, IMO the makers of the BIOPS video have done a fantastic job. Kudos. I gather future episodes of the series will tackle different conceptions of posthuman superintelligence - not least from the MIRI perspective.

Reply
[-]somervta12y00

It... was, wasn't it? Or did I mistake the bit about David Pearce and the elimination of suffering?

Reply
[-]knb12y00

It was. I'm saying I don't think it should have been.

Reply
[-][anonymous]12y00

/

[This comment is no longer endorsed by its author]Reply
[-]somervta12y00

Thanks for posting this - I had seen it elsewhere, but forgot to watch it, and I never knew about the Kickstarter

Reply
Moderation Log
More from Joshua_Blaine
View more
Curated and popular this week
12Comments

http://youtu.be/bTMS9y8OVuY

I think this is a nice introduction to Transhumanism, inspired by the style of many well known Youtube educators. Given how much LessWrong likes these ideas, I thought it was worth sharing.

The group also has a Kickstarter here to fund an entire series of videos of this kind. I think they deserve to be backed, and LW can probably influence the video creators in a useful/helpful way.