If Less Wrong wants people to be sharing more of their intellectual output on this website, we should probably be looking at Substack since it probably scores best in terms of being both successful and similar.
Whilst I expect there are many features that would make sense to copy over, the feature I am focusing on today is subtitles.
A good title is focused on being memorable and catching the readers attention, maybe you'd prefer for everyone to just make their titles as descriptive as possible, but expecting that to work feels naive to me. In contrast, subtitles address this issue systematically: the title catches the user's attention and the subtitle tells you clearly what the article actually focuses on, so you can decide whether it is worth your time or not.
I'm not claiming that this feature will radically transform this website, but it would be a relatively simple feature to add, so I think the cost-benefit ratio would be pretty good. Beware Trivial Inconveniences comes to mind. Insofar as people chose to prioritize other platforms, I suspect that often a bunch of small features like this end up making the difference.
I don't feel strongly for or against this idea, but I don't see how it makes LW a better place to share your own writing. Is the idea that it would increase the audience for each post, and posters want a larger audience? I would think that the LW frontpage already has a moderate-to-large audience-size advantage over most people's personal Substacks.
(Checking this: Claude estimates 3-7k LW homepage visits per day, and 1-3k readers for a typical post in its first week. This is way below a big Substack's numbers, of course, but in the range of a lot of established, in-the-conversation rationalist Substacks I subscribe to.)
I don't see how it makes LW a better place to share your own writing
Even though it is theoretically possible that authors only use subtitles because they feel forced to by other authors using it, I would suggest that our default should be to assume that subtitles developed for a reason.
If Less Wrong wants people to be sharing more of their intellectual output on this website, we should probably be looking at Substack since it probably scores best in terms of being both successful and similar.
Whilst I expect there are many features that would make sense to copy over, the feature I am focusing on today is subtitles.
A good title is focused on being memorable and catching the readers attention, maybe you'd prefer for everyone to just make their titles as descriptive as possible, but expecting that to work feels naive to me. In contrast, subtitles address this issue systematically: the title catches the user's attention and the subtitle tells you clearly what the article actually focuses on, so you can decide whether it is worth your time or not.
I'm not claiming that this feature will radically transform this website, but it would be a relatively simple feature to add, so I think the cost-benefit ratio would be pretty good. Beware Trivial Inconveniences comes to mind. Insofar as people chose to prioritize other platforms, I suspect that often a bunch of small features like this end up making the difference.