A core tenet of Bayesianism is that probability is in the mind. But it seems to me that even hardcore Bayesians can waffle a bit when it comes to the possibility that quantum probabilities are irreducible physical probabilities.
I don’t know enough about quantum physics to lay things out in any detailed disagreement, but it seems to me that if one finds a system that one cannot consistently make predictions for, it means we lack the knowledge to predict the systems, not that the system involves physical, outside-the-mind probabilities. For example, I could never predict the exact pattern of raindrops the next time it rains, but no one argues that that means those probabilities are therefore physical.
What is the Bayesian argument, if one exists, for why quantum dynamics breaks the “probability is in the mind” philosophy?
The Born probabilities are in the mind under the MWI! Reality just has the amplitudes
Which are pretty similar. They are objective feature of the territory that tell you how likely you are to see things.
And note that MWI features really existing possible worlds, in that it features a
a multiplicity of existing actual worlds...and what is actual is possible. What MWI removes is chance.
And note that the argument from MWI doesn't support "probability is in the Mind" as it is usually stated, because it is usually stated as something that is true unconditionally, and MWI is only one possibility.
A core tenet of Bayesianism is that probability is in the mind. But it seems to me that even hardcore Bayesians can waffle a bit when it comes to the possibility that quantum probabilities are irreducible physical probabilities.
I don’t know enough about quantum physics to lay things out in any detailed disagreement, but it seems to me that if one finds a system that one cannot consistently make predictions for, it means we lack the knowledge to predict the systems, not that the system involves physical, outside-the-mind probabilities. For example, I could never predict the exact pattern of raindrops the next time it rains, but no one argues that that means those probabilities are therefore physical.
What is the Bayesian argument, if one exists, for why quantum dynamics breaks the “probability is in the mind” philosophy?