This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
“eg Most of a human's personal welfare depends on the country of their birth which is not due to their own behavior.”
But it was dependent on their ancestors’ behavior. And so insofar as you view tribes/ethnic groups/countries as playing games with/against each other, then the same logic applies at that higher level.
Now you might reject that viewpoint, and take a purely individualist stance. But my claim above is (loosely, I haven’t made it precise yet) that the point of ethics is to move us beyond thinking of ourselves as individual units, so that we can make decisions as a larger-scale moral agent.
And from the perspective of the larger moral agent you’re instantiated within, there’s a big difference between people who were born in your home country and people born on other continents—because the former are part of that same moral agent to a much greater degree than the latter. (And yes, they may be worse at “being part of the moral superagent” than a foreigner would be. But this is all negotiated via Schelling points in games between millions of agents, so you can’t just pick and choose your coalition. You need an initiation ritual like a naturalization process or a judicial trial to change that coalition.) Analogously, some of your time-slices are less good at “being Eli” (according to your dominant identity narrative) than time-slices of some other people. But it’s still just for them to benefit or lose out based on the actions of your other time-slices.
(Written quickly on phone, please forgive infelicities of phrasing.)