This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Okay, so trying to combine Prisoner's dilemma and UDT, we get: A and B are in a prisoner's dilemma. Suppose they have a list of N agents (which include, say, A's past self, B's past self, the Buddha, etc), and they each must commit to following one of those agent's instructions. Each of them estimates: "conditional on me committing to listen to agent K, here's a distribution over which agent they'd commit to listen to" And then you maximize expected value based on that.
Okay, but why isn't this exactly the same as them just thinking to themselves "conditional on me taking action K, here's the distribution over their actions" for each of N actions they could take, and then maximizing expected value? It feels like the difference is that it's really hard to actually reason about the correlations between my low-level actions and your low-level actions, whereas it might be easier to reason about the correlations between my high-level commitments and your high-level commitments.
I.e. the role of the Buddha in this situation is just to make the acausal coordination here much easier.