This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
To be clear, my claims aren't meant to be conditional on the idea that these tweets will be helpful. I do not consider the DoD account to be doing a robustly good thing, and that's related to why I'm not making tweets like that myself.
Instead, the thing I'm doing is more like inaction: people want me to say "this is reprehensible", and I am declining to make such a statement. In general, inaction is often a more robust strategy than action (especially when the "null policy" is as obvious as "decline to make a statement").
I think the main way that this strategy might be non-robust is if I'm declining to criticize the right while also getting triggered by analogous behavior from leftists and calling them names. To some extent I've made this mistake over the last year by e.g. not speaking up more about ways that Trump is behaving badly (e.g. various kinds of corruption), and I intend to fix that.
On a psychological level, I've spent the last few years trying to carve out space to be publicly honest about very controversial topics, and forceful on issues where it does matter, without wildly lashing out at the cowardice and malfeasance of the vast majority of Western elites. There's something here reminiscent of Scott Alexander's description in Kolmogorov complicity: "A medieval monk being told God doesn’t exist probably has a lot of questions. He’s likely to go kind of crazy for a while, crave the worldview-shards that he needs to rebuild his fractured philosophy." I think I steered well clear of the "going crazy" attractor, but did have a period where I was doing more lashing out than I currently endorse. However, on a meta level I still endorse erring in that direction rather than the direction of being too careful (because almost everyone like me errs in the latter direction not the former).
I really do appreciate advice on how to balance this better, but unfortunately most of the advice that I receive roughly boils down to "be more careful", which can easily function as a general-purpose suppressant of novel thinking. For example, when ML researchers looked at old LessWrong arguments about AGI, they could find arbitrarily many ways to dismiss it for not being careful enough. Similarly, at OpenAI I remember many cases of people trying to convince others to be more careful in order to preserve their political capital, where actually the thing that was going on was mostly them being scared of Sam getting mad at them. (And Tyler Cowen very recently critiqued AI safety for not being careful enough, in such a one-sided way that even his own commenters called him out.)