This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
I think there are non-cowardly reasons to view someone's political opinions as disqualifying for a senior role in AI alignment research. It would be cowardly to say "your views are controversial and will turn people off", but not to say "your views are reprehensible and cause us to genuinely trust you less to do a good job at work that is not just narrowly technical but creative and philosophical and sometimes even moral in nature."
Now, you did say they explicitly talked about optics (in terms of recruitment). In general I am pretty down on doing things because of optics, though I do concede that it can be instrumentally necessary for getting things done in this messed-up world. But it's also very possible that the object level matters to them too. I don't think all views are equally worthy of taking a costly stand for.