This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
It seems to me that Richard isn't trying to bring back ethnonationalism, or even trying to "add just that touch of ethnic pride back into the meme pool", but just trying to diagnose "how the western world got so dysfunctional". If ethnonationalism and the taboo against ethnonationalism are both bad (as an ethnic minority I'm personally pretty scared of the former), then maybe we should get rid of the taboo and defend against ethnonationalism by other means, similar how there is little to no taboo against communism[1] but it hasn't come close to taking power or reapproaching its historical high water mark in the west.
If you doubt this, there's an advisor to my local school district who is a self-avowed Marxist and professor of education at the state university, and writes book reviews like this one: «For decades the educational Left and critical pedagogues have run away from Marxism, socialism, and communism, all too often based on faulty understandings and falling prey to the deep-seated anti-communism in the academy. In History and Education Curry Stephenson Malott pushes back against this trend by offering us deeply Marxist thinking about the circulation of capital, socialist states, the connectivity of Marxist anti-capitalism, and a politics of race and education. In the process Malott points toward the role of education in challenging us all to become abolitionists of global capitalism.» (Wayne Au, Associate Professor in the School of Educational Studies at the University of Washington Bothell; Editor of the social justice teaching magazine Rethinking Schools; Co-editor of Mapping Corporate Education Reform: Power and Policies Networks in the Neoliberal State)