This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
(One way I think about politics is that one faction has refused to consider "without creating bad incentives" and in response the other faction is now polarizing towards refusing to consider "help those people". And we've now reached the point where these refusals commonly serve as vice signals on each side.)
I relate to this. There's the guys who (sometimes) understand incentives and the guys who (sometimes) show any compassion.
Relatedly, It seems like most of the intellectuals that have anything like an accurate model of the sociology of morality (eg moral signaling, and gaslighting-games over what the moral norms already are, so as to move the social-morality accounting of what what constitutes a "good person", etc.) are almost all self-consciously selfish, and dismissive of unselfish motivation. And on the other side there are people who do still aspire to compassion or goodness, but who are blind to, or deluded about, or lying about, the mechanisms of moral politics.
(Notably, one philosopher who self-consciously believes in moral goodness, and also has anything like accurate modeling of moral sociology, is Lasota, who is a likely (though not yet convicted) murderer. I find that frustrating and depressing.
Eliezer hasn't written as much about the moral-politics and how they shape in-practice moral norms, but he probably also has pretty good models here, and his soul clearly rings with some vibrant commitment to goodness.)