This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
This might escalate to the government trying to arrest him, and outright conflict, but honestly if Superman isn't skillful enough to defuse that kind of thing, given his influence, then he doesn't have much business imposing political changes on the world anyway.
This seems like a weird set of claims to me.
First of all, yes, it seems very likely to escalate to conflict? Many nations would consider Superman's property damage to their factories to be an act of war by a foreign power, and that he's doing it in ways that technically circumvent existing laws is not going to make much of a difference. (That seems more annoying actually.)
He could try to negotiate for big, universal, changes to the food supply chain via diplomatic channels, backed by offers to trade various things he can provide, which generally seems like a better way to go about it. But if push comes to shove, I think he should back up his demands with effectively military intervention, if that could work. (Actually, my guess is that if he's resorting to violence, he should mainly be relying on targeted assassinations.)
Also, the factory farming is not the only evil that our hypothetical superman should end. I think he should probably initiate regime changes in various authoritarian or dictatorial countries (eg North Korea, Eritrea, Afghanistan), or otherwise enable residents to leave the territory of those regimes. Again, he should attempt to negotiate for that diplomatically, first, but this is very clearly against the core interests of those regimes, and it seems very likely that he's going to end up going to war with them.
Are you saying that if the diplomatic negotiations deteriorate to the point of military action, that means that our hypothetical superman has failed, and he would be better off retiring? Don't existing legitimate countries go to war for far less noble reasons all the time?
I do think that having a superman around is extremely scary, and among other things, he should make the standards that he's enforcing extremely clear and legible. He should make a point to never be capricious. He should write clear manifestos declaring the moral principles that he's upholding and the logic behind them. And if his principles change for some reason, he should telegraph that very clearly. He should telegraph his actions with a lot of lead time, so that he's a predictable agent to make plans around.
But ultimately he should declare:
Factory farms and oppressive regimes that people are not allowed to leave should not be allowed to exist. I am open to negotiations regarding the safest and stablest and overal best path toward ending those institutions. But that they are ending is not open to negotiation. After an offramp plan has been agreed to, or if the international community cannot reach a consensus on an offramp plan, I will oppose anyone maintaining these institutions, with superpowered military force.
If you don't like that, tough noogies for you. Your national sovereignty is not more sacred than the sentient rights on which your actions are infringing."
This is basically how I would want a hegemonic morally-motivated nation-state to behave.
What standard do you want to hold our superman / morally-motivated nation state to?