This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
In general when we do intellectual work we have excellent epistemic standards, capable of listening to all sorts of evidence that other communities and fields would throw out, and listening to subtler evidence than most scientists ("faster than science")
"Being more openminded about what evidence to listen to" seems like a way in which we have lower epistemic standards than scientists, and also that's beneficial. It doesn't rebut my claim that there are some ways in which we have lower epistemic standards than many academic communities, and that's harmful.
In particular, the relevant question for me is: why doesn't LW have more depth? Sure, more depth requires more work, but on the timeframe of several years, and hundreds or thousands of contributors, it seems viable. And I'm proposing, as a hypothesis, that LW doesn't have enough depth because people don't care enough about depth - they're willing to accept ideas even before they've been explored in depth. If this explanation is correct, then it seems accurate to call it a problem with our epistemic standards - specifically, the standard of requiring (and rewarding) deep investigation and scholarship.