In trying to reply to this comment I identified four "waves" of AI safety, and lists of the central people in each wave. Since this is socially complicated I'll only share the full list of the first wave here, and please note that this is all based on fuzzy intuitions gained via gossip and other unreliable sources.
The first wave I’ll call the “founders”; I think of them as the people who set up the early institutions and memeplexes of AI safety before around 2015. My list:
The second wave I’ll call the “old guard”; those were the people who joined or supported the founders before around 2015. A few central examples include Paul Christiano, Chris Olah, Andrew Critch and Oliver Habryka.
Around 2014/2015 AI safety became significantly more professionalized and growth-oriented. Bostrom published Superintelligence, the Puerto Rico conference happened, OpenAI was founded, DeepMind started a safety team (though I don't recall exactly when), and EA started seriously pushing people towards AI safety. I’ll call the people who entered the field from then until around 2020 "safety scalers" (though I'm open to better names). A few central examples include Miles Brundage, Beth Barnes, John Wentworth, Rohin Shah, Dan Hendrycks and myself.
And then there’s the “newcomers” who joined in the last 5-ish years. I have a worse mental map of these people, but some who I respect are Leo Gao, Sahil, Marius Hobbhahn and Jesse Hoogland.
In this comment I expressed concern that my generation (by which I mean the "safety scalers") have kinda given up on solving alignment. But another higher-level concern is: are people from these last two waves the kinds of people who would have been capable of founding AI safety in the first place? And if not, where are those people now? Of course there's some difference in the skills required for founding a field vs pushing the field forward, but to a surprising extent I keep finding that the people who I have the most insightful conversations with are the ones who were around from the very beginning. E.g. I think Vassar is the single person doing the best thinking about the lessons we can learn about failures of AI safety over the last decade (though he's hard to interface with), and Yudkowsky is still the single person who's most able to push the Overton window towards taking alignment seriously (even though in principle many other people could have written (less doomy versions of) his Time op-ed or his recent book), Scott is still the single best blogger in the space, and so on.
Relatedly, when I talk to someone who's exceptionally thoughtful about politics (and particularly the psychological aspects of politics), a disturbingly large proportion of the time it turns out that worked at (or were somehow associated with) Leverage. This is really weird to me. Maybe I just have Leverage-aligned tastes/networks, but even so, it's a very striking effect. (Also, how come there's no young Moldbug?)
Assuming that I'm gesturing at something real, what are some possible explanations?
This is all only a rough gesture at the phenomenon, and you should be wary that I'm just being pessimistic rather than identifying something important. Also it's a hard topic to talk about clearly because it's loaded with a bunch of social baggage. But I do feel pretty confused and want to figure this stuff out.