This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
"I see a lot of (very high quality) raw energy here that wants shaping and directing, with the use of lots of tools for coordination (e.g. better collaboration tools)."
Yepp, I agree with this. I guess our main disagreement is whether the "low epistemic standards" framing is a useful way to shape that energy. I think it is because it'll push people towards realising how little evidence they actually have for many plausible-seeming hypotheses on this website. One proven claim is worth a dozen compelling hypotheses, but LW to a first approximation only produces the latter.
When you say "there's also a lot of space for more 'details' to get fleshed out and subquestions to be cleanly answered", I find myself expecting that this will involve people who believe the hypothesis continuing to build their castle in the sky, not analysis about why it might be wrong and why it's not.
That being said, LW is very good at producing "fake frameworks". So I don't want to discourage this too much. I'm just arguing that this is a different thing from building robust knowledge about the world.