This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
seems like a good place to ask something I’ve been meaning to ask you for a while: how familiar are you with the lineage that influenced Land? How much Deleuze, Spinoza, Frankfurt School, Lacan, Foucault, Gramsci, Agamben, Latour, Hegel, Negri, Heidegger, etc have you read?
I like some things about your thinking but often you state things as revelatory, or in this case appeal to pushing the frontier, in a way that makes it seem like you might not have spent much time with the influences of some of the thinkers who influence you. This isn’t a huge deal; attribution is really hard! But at present when you imply originality (or something weaker) in a particular thinker or idea, I tend to heavily down-weight that implication.
To be clear: I’m not intending to be at all censorious or credentialist, and I’m not endorsing any of these thinkers in particular. I’m concerned about things like:
I’m missing something (because whatever point you made didn’t strike me as profound, while it clearly struck you as such), and you’re trying to signal that the reader may be missing something, and I’m down weighting that signal, and so continue to miss it.
You’re sacrificing some credibility among audiences with more canonical background by making what appear to be claims about the history of philosophy, which are actually side points and not well-backed (if they are intended as claims about the history of philosophy). This also limits the robustness of your arguments in the hands of those who are convinced by them.
You’re actually trying to mostly argue about history of philosophy but are just pretty wrong because your survey of the history has been biased away from thinkers you view as political opponents (I don’t think the strong version of this critique is true; Richard is very much not intellectually xenophobic, but weaker versions may be).
My models of the history here are very cracked, or I'm missing extremely important points that happen to come to me in forms against which I am intellectually xenophobic (I am much more intellectually xenophobic than Richard).
I don't consider your answer to this question much evidence of anything; I've been intending to, e.g., go through your course, and consult my library, and share my maps and so on, but I just haven't had the time, so this is more of an orienting question for some future thinking I hope to do soon*.
I realize this kind of question is usually very adversarial, and we are probably adversaries, so I'd like to point to this comment I made on a post of yours as (some) evidence that I'm asking in good faith!