This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Some thoughts on public outreach and "Were they early because they were good or lucky?"
Who are the best newcomers to AI safety? I'd be interested to here anyone's takes, not just Richard's. Who has done great work (by your lights) since joining after ChatGPT?
Rob Miles was the high watermark of public outreach. Unfortunately he stopped making videos. I'd be far more excited by a newcomer if they were persuaded by a Rob Miles video than an 80K video -- videos like 80K's "We're Not Ready for Superintelligence"[1] are better on legible/easy-to-measure dimensions but worse in some more important way I think.
I observe a suspicious amount of 'social contagion' among the pre-ChatGPT AI Safety crowd, which updates me somewhat in favour of "lucky" over "good".[2]
A bit anecdotal but: there are ~ a dozen people who went to our college in 2017-2020 now working full-time in AI safety, which is much higher than other colleges at the same university. I'm not saying any of us are particularly "great" -- but this suggests social contagion / information cascade, rather than "we figured this stuff out from the empty string". Maybe if you go back further (e.g. 2012-2016) there was less social contagion, and that cohort is better?