This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Talking to Richard and hiring Richard are two different things. It's plausible to me that all these things are true simultaneously:
Richard would do a great job at contributing useful research directions / thoughts / etc.
Richard would be great for the org culture and treat everyone well / respectfully / etc.
Richard's politics have substantial admixtures of attitudes that are dumb (both incorrect and harmful), and indicative of general attitudes / thought patterns that are reasonably taken as hostile / toxic / etc.
Other good people have low thresholds for that sort of indication, for good reasons, and in fact would be less likely to join and/or fund the org if Richard is there
The expected net effect of hiring Richard is negative, including integrity / upholding principles (it's not necessarily unprincipled to be like "I think Richard's ideas are good enough that it's worth some tail risk, but I get that lots of other good people wouldn't have that information, and furthermore have good reason to distrust him for political reasons, so I won't hire him")
I would not guess that all of these are true, but I wouldn't be so confident without, for example, having talked to several potential hires for the org.