This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
I appreciate your sincere and principled engagement, but I also want to note that there's something oddly mistake-theory-ish about a bunch of your comments. I first noticed it with the "reprehensible" comment, where it seemed like you were assuming a bunch of common knowledge that didn't actually exist—like you were using terminology that doesn't make sense to use when talking to an audience that would downvote that comment to -61.
And now here, where you say "seems like this would be an orthogonal dimension from competence, intelligence, integrity and other things you also want to select on" as if that's something other people will nod along to, whereas it seems more likely that most people who read this will think "no it's not, my political enemies are actually just low-integrity and incompetent and dumb".
It seems like there's something important about the dynamics of leftists and liberals that you're not modeling right now. It's a bit analogous to a thread I had with Kelsey where I called her out for continually using the phrase "I don't understand why" because it seemed obvious that she was doing motivated cognition to block out her actual hypotheses. My best guess is that you're trying to maintain some attitude of "we're all reasonable people here" which is in fact no longer true about LessWrong with respect to modern politics (and also that updating on this would gradually lead you to a strategy much more similar to mine than your current strategy is).
(Flagging that this is a somewhat low-effort comment because I'm feeling a bit lazy right now, so please don't take it as me expressing strong/robust opinions about your internal state.)