This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Thanks for elaborating this interesting critique. I agree we generally need to be more critical of our abstractions.
I haven't seen you give arguments that your models [of instrumental convergence] are [useful for realistic agents]
Falsifying claims and "breaking" proposals is a classic element of AI alignment discourse and debate. Since we're talking about superintelligent agents, we can't predict exactly what a proposal would do. However, if I make a claim ("a superintelligent paperclip maximizer would keep us around because of gains from trade"), you can falsify this by showing that my claimed policy is dominated by another class of policies ("we would likely be comically resource-inefficient in comparison; GFT arguments don't model dynamics which allow killing other agents and appropriating their resources").
Even we can come up with this dominant policy class, so the posited superintelligence wouldn't miss it either. We don't know what the superintelligent policy will be, but we know what it won't be (see also Formalizing convergent instrumental goals). Even though I don't know how Gary Kasparov will open the game, I confidently predict that he won't let me checkmate him in two moves.
Non-optimal power and instrumental convergence
Instead of thinking about optimal policies, let's consider the performance of a given algorithm A. A(M,R) takes a rewardless MDP M and a reward function R as input, and outputs a policy.
Definition. Let R be a continuous distribution over reward functions with CDF F. The average return achieved by algorithm A at state s and discount rate γ is
∫RVA(M,R)R(s,γ)dF(R).
Instrumental convergence with respect to A's policies can be defined similarly ("what is the R-measure of a given trajectory under A?"). The theory I've laid out allows precise claims, which is a modest benefit to our understanding. Before, we just had intuitions about some vague concept called "instrumental convergence".
Here's bad reasoning, which implies that the cow tears a hole in spacetime:
Suppose the laws of physics bestow godhood upon an agent executing some convoluted series of actions; in particular, this allows avoiding heat death. Clearly, it is optimal for the vast majority of agents to instantly become god.
The problem is that it's impractical to predict what a smarter agent will do, or what specific kinds of action will be instrumentally convergent for A, or that the real agent would be infinitely smart. Just because it's smart doesn't mean it's omniscient, as you rightly point out.
Here's better reasoning:
Suppose that the MDP modeling the real world represents shutdown as a single terminal state. Most optimal agents don't allow themselves to be shut down. Furthermore, since we can see that most goals offer better reward at non-shutdown states, superintelligent A can as well.[1] While I don't know exactly what Awill tend to do, I predict that policies generated by A will tend to resist shutdown.
It might seem like I'm assuming the consequent here. This is not so – the work is first done by the theorems on optimal behavior, which do imply that most goals achieve greater return by avoiding shutdown. The question is whether reasonably intelligent suboptimal agents realize this fact. Given a uniformly drawn reward function, we can usually come up with a better policy than dying, so the argument is that A can as well. ↩︎