This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
As mentioned in my reply to Ruby, this is not a critique of the LW team, but of the LW mentality. And I should have phrased my point more carefully - "epistemic standards are too low to make any progress" is clearly too strong a claim, it's more like "epistemic standards are low enough that they're an important bottleneck to progress". But I do think there's a substantive disagreement here. Perhaps the best way to spell it out is to look at the posts you linked and see why I'm less excited about them than you are.
Of the top posts in the 2018 review, and the ones you linked (excluding AI), I'd categorise them as follows:
Interesting speculation about psychology and society, where I have no way of knowing if it's true:
Local Validity as a Key to Sanity and Civilization
The Loudest Alarm Is Probably False
Anti-social punishment (which is, unlike the others, at least based on one (1) study).
Babble
Intelligent social web
Unrolling social metacognition
Simulacra levels
Can you keep this secret?
Same as above but it's by Scott so it's a bit more rigorous and much more compelling:
Is Science Slowing Down?
The tails coming apart as a metaphor for life
Useful rationality content:
Toolbox-thinking and law-thinking
A sketch of good communication
Varieties of argumentative experience
Review of basic content from other fields. This seems useful for informing people on LW, but not actually indicative of intellectual progress unless we can build on them to write similar posts on things that *aren't* basic content in other fields:
Voting theory primer
Prediction markets: when do they work
Costly coordination mechanism of common knowledge (Note: I originally said I hadn't seen many examples of people building on these ideas, but at least for this post there seems to be a lot.)
Six economics misconceptions
Swiss political system
It's pretty striking to me how much the original sequences drew on the best academic knowledge, and how little most of the things above draw on the best academic knowledge. And there's nothing even close to the thoroughness of Luke's literature reviews.
The three things I'd like to see more of are:
1. The move of saying "Ah, this is interesting speculation about a complex topic. It seems compelling, but I don't have good ways of verifying it; I'll treat it like a plausible hypothesis which could be explored more by further work." (I interpret the thread I originally linked as me urging Wei to do this).
2. Actually doing that follow-up work. If it's an empirical hypothesis, investigating empirically. If it's a psychological hypothesis, does it apply to anyone who's not you? If it's more of a philosophical hypothesis, can you identify the underlying assumptions and the ways it might be wrong? In all cases, how does it fit into existing thought? (That'll probably take much more than a single blog post).
3. Insofar as many of these scattered plausible insights are actually related in deep ways, trying to combine them so that the next generation of LW readers doesn't have to separately learn about each of them, but can rather download a unified generative framework.