This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
I find this an interesting line of criticism, it is essentially pointing at the difficulty of finding good evidence and evaluating yourself on that evidence and making a disagreement about how easy it is.
I would like to bring in a perspective of more first principles modelling of how quickly you incorporate evidence pointing against the way you're thinking.
One thing is the amount of disconfirming evidence you look for. Another thing is your ability to bring that information into your worldview, your openness to being wrong. Thirdly we might also mention is the speed of the feedback, how long time does it take for you to get feedback.
I think you're saying that when you go into virtue ethics we often find failures in bringing in disconcerting information into a worldview. I don't think this has to be the case personally as I do think there are ways to actually get feedback on whether you're acting in a way that is aligned with your virtues, by mentioning examples of them and then having anonymous people give feedback or just normal reflection.
This is a lot easier to do if your loops are shorter which is the exact point that consequentalism and utilitarianism can fail on, it is a target that is quite far away and so the crispness and locality of the feedback is not high enough.
I think that virtue ethics outperforms consequentialism because it is better suited for bringing in information as well as for speed and crispness of that information. I personally think it is because it is a game theory optimal solution to consequentialism in environments where you have little information but that is probably beside the point.
This might just be a difference in terminology though? Would you agree with my 3 point characterisation above?