This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
I agree with claims that we don't have AGI now, and I'd put reasonable probability that we don't get a superintelligence in 8 years (maybe around 70%?)
And yes, some short timelines people have to update now (thinking of you @Nathan Helm-Burger) But not all short timelines people have to update, like Shane Legg, for example.
I previously noted that we’re seeing a pretty sharp divergence between the measured capabilities of models and their real-world impacts
I feel like this is probably the largest disagreement by far. I'd sympathize for 2025-era models for coding, but I now think we have much more hard evidence that AI models are useful beyond benchmarks, and I think the best example of this is the way OpenAI and Anthropic's ARR accelerated in 2026 because coding models finally became good enough that you could use it as a subsitute rather than a complement, unless you have extremely good coding skills now.
There are still areas where humans can productively contribute, but more and more of this is non-coding tasks.
I think the main way in which short timeline predictions were wrong is that people underestimated how jagged the frontier was for AIs, because they incorrectly used human baselines, and as it turns out models can be much more competent at some things without being good at other things, which creates pretty severe bottlenecks to fully automating something, and it's only with full automation of something where things tend to explode.
And conditional on the intelligence explosion/superintelligence in 8 years claim being wrong, I expect to see a similar pattern.
On this:
people go straight from "an intelligence explosion soon is plausible" to "okay, what do I do about it?"
A lot of the resson for this is basically due to hedging, and contra you I think this is entirely rational and expected under worldviews where AI safety is the main problem, compared to the other problems of AI, and not purely emotional bandwagoning.
Now, I don't think this is super-useful as a scenario to focus on, and I agree we shouldn't unthinkingly assume RSI soon, but that's because I expect better futures work to outweigh AI safety work in a very large percentage of scenarios.
I will also say that despite disagreeing with you on the details, I also agree that posts like @Alexander Gietelink Oldenziel's Superintelligence by Christmas is pure clickbait, and the fact that it was voted to 61 karma before my strong downvote is a bad sign of the epistemics of this forum.