This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
So, they are writing fictional analogies for the situation they expect to actually happen in real life. Except of course, since they are writing fiction, it has to have a happy ending.
Well, exactly what I'm disputing here is how happy the ending is. For example, imagine that all of these stories played out exactly the same, with the exact same amount of concentration of power. But instead of the heroes getting to use that power to reshape the world, the power instead goes to.... a random person off the street. I expect that these authors, if they were to write that kind of ending, would portray it as a maybe-happy-ish ending, but one that's still pretty scary and uncertain.
And indeed, this is roughly how I'd describe the stories mentioned above where a mostly-aligned AI gets total power—Friendship is Optimal, Branches on the Tree of Time, and Metamorphosis of Prime Intellect. These stories really grapple with the sense of unease and tension that comes with almost everyone losing almost all their power.
Whereas when I look at the examples of ratfic above, the stance they're taking seems to be "our heroes became dictators of the universe. This is a straightforwardly happy ending." And indeed, on several occasions (maybe as many as half a dozen?) I've heard people describe the ending of Worth the Candle as one of the best utopias they can imagine. All of this really seems like a big ideological blind spot.