This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
I think the tweets above are probably reprehensible by the norms of liberal elites from maybe 50-80 years ago. Unfortunately, these norms have not decayed in a random fashion, but rather specifically in ways that make them a useful vehicle for the illiberal left. I'll quote from my exchange with Kelsey:
Unfortunately, I view modern self-identified liberalism as being pretty hollowed out, in the sense that it keeps the trappings of actual liberalism but concedes most object-level battles to the woke left, pushing back on its excesses at each point in time but not challenging the foundations (and therefore continually losing ground for most of the last century). Some examples of lines it could have drawn:
- meritocracy (as opposed to affirmative action, disparate impact, etc) - freedom of association (even if it’s “sexist” or “racist”) - property rights (as opposed to environmentalist regulations) - cultural compatibility as a key immigration criterion (as opposed to many things since at least Hart-Cellar)
So from my perspective, modern “liberalism” is in part defined by its lack of ability to pin down a position it won’t retreat from. Which then makes it hard for me to engage with it without violating the discourse norms you mention above (though, again, I appreciate why that might be frustrating from your perspective).
To be clear, the version of liberal norms upheld by LessWrong is maybe the least hollowed out of any community in the world. But that’s *still* not enough for people on LessWrong to be able to honestly discuss what's going on. For example, LessWrong is able to track ways that MAGA bluntly breaks norms, but is unwilling/unable to recognize the extent of the more cumulative/distributed norm-breaking from smarter and more coordinated leftists. (Ben Hoffman put it as follows: "the main thing that causes Trump's bad behavior to stand out is the extent to which it is different than the sorts of correlated bad behavior that powerful coalitions get away with.")
See for instance this recent piece on the closing of the internet, an enormously important phenomenon which LessWrong has largely failed to track or oppose because a lot of it was justified in terms of suppressing the "far right". Rationalists did a better job with covid, but still largely focused on experts being object-level wrong, rather than trying to understand how and why networks of experts could have been so unethical and incompetent. As a third example, LessWrong isn't willing to reason clearly about the extent of population-level differences, and therefore vastly underestimates how different America would look if its laws and institutions were race-neutral (more here and here).
So there are two reasons why I'm not upholding the liberal norm of calling the DoD tweets reprehensible. The first is that I don't want to participate in the process by which the facade of liberal norms is used to steer society towards illiberal leftism. The second is that the extent to which actual liberalism has lost to leftism suggests that even early liberal norms were actually not stable, and we'll need to come up with a new set of norms which work better. I'm trying to figure that out (as are a few others, like Ben and Hazard) but it's rare for people to be both analytically-minded enough to take on this kind of project, and brave enough to propagate the implications of taboo-violating knowledge throughout their worldview. (Ben has an interesting post on the difficulty of such propagation in LLMs here.)