This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Are you saying that if the diplomatic negotiations deteriorate to the point of military action, that means that our hypothetical superman has failed, and he would be better off retiring? Don't existing legitimate countries go to war for far less noble reasons all the time?
I indended this to refer to scenarios where the US itself (or other leading western powers) were taking military action against Superman. I care much less about whether he destabilizes North Korea or Eritrea or even countries similar to those but better-governed. But I care a lot about whether he destabilizes the countries I consider the best and most important ones.
Many nations would consider Superman's property damage to their factories to be an act of war by a foreign power
Maybe. Or maybe they really wouldn't want to pick a fight with Superman. Or maybe they would issue an angry press release then not do anything. In a setting where Superman holds basically all the cards in terms of physical force, most nations would try quite hard to defuse tensions with him (unless, as I discussed, he's very unskilled).