This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
The intended implication is something like "rationalists have a bias towards treating statements as much firmer commitments than intended then getting very upset when they are violated".
For example, unless I'm missing something, the "we do not wish to advance the rate of AI capabilities" claim is just one offhand line in a blog post. It's not a firm commitment, it's not even a claim about what their intentions are. As stated, it's just one consideration that informs their actions - and in fact the "wish" terminology is often specifically not a claim about intended actions (e.g. "I wish I didn't have to do X").
Yet rationalists are hammering them on this one sentence - literally making songs about it, tweeting it to criticize Anthropic, etc. It seems like there is a serious lack of metacognition about where a non-adversarial communication breakdown could have occurred, or what the charitable interpretations of this are.
(I am open to people considering them then dismissing them, but I'm not even seeing that. Like, if people were saying "I understand the difference between Anthropic actually making an organizational commitment, and just offhand mentioning a fact about their motivations, but here's why I'm disappointed anyway", that seems reasonable. But a lot of people seem to be treating it as a Very Serious Promise being broken.)