This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
The org is trying to hire Agent Foundations researchers. Suppose that becoming such a researcher requires being educated, but the education system usually infects the candidates with leftism in a manner which doesn't affect their ability to make advancements. Then Ngo would end up hostile to 84% of potential candidates and not to 84% of the population.
As far as I understand Ngo, he worries that leftism either does affect the ability to make advancements or is a demonstration that the researchers are stumped by lack of diversity. For example, if the researcher tried to extrapolate human mechanisms of value emergence onto the AIs while believing in the wrong mechanisms, then the researcher would produce slop. Or, taking an example from my comment, if a sociologist tried to explain wokeness with feminization of academia, then the true explanation would have to account for other factors which the West, unlike Russia, experienced.
P.S. Ngo also claims that "the weight I place on these points is strongly influenced by my background views on how the alignment community keeps failing to achieve its goals (and often adopts strategies that actively backfire). I'm writing up a much longer and more detailed post on these background views, and intend to post a public version sometime next week." Alas, the three examples which he cites aren't THAT clear to me: academia's inability to grapple with either AGI or AGI risk, the costs of intellectual taboos which are much larger than most people expected and the idea that "AI safety is in a much worse position today than it would have been if it'd taken a more principled truth-seeking stance a decade ago (for example, AI governance would have been less likely to throw in with the Democrats in a way that alienated MAGA)." The third point is complex because IMHO AI governance does require international coordination to avoid the AI-2027-like race. The first point has a benign explanation.