This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Looking over the [edit: specific] cited tweets and tweet conversation, I don't get it.
This seems really quite tame? Richard is laying out an abstract taxonomy of views nationhood, and critiquing them. Then he has a cordial exchange with Kelsey, in which she requests and he attempts to pass her ITT (and does a good job according to her). This all seems polite, reasonable, and well within the norms of online intellectual political discourse?
I notice I'm confused.
Are there more tweets that I couldn't find?
Do I radically misunderstand what reasonable people find offensive?
Is even this level of political analysis verboten in conventional professional circles?
Should I update that resolution has really different standards than I do, or is exceptionally cowardly with regard to possible social attacks?
Do they have a spidey-sense that Richard endorsing the "national right" view is too close to ethnonationalism, which is too close to racism, and that potential employees wouldn't want to work for Resolution, because Richard is also employed there? (To which I'm like, "Are you kidding me? Even if that's true, why do you want to work with such people?")
Are their real concerns about Richard something else, which is inappropriate to cite for some reason, so they're citing this instead?
It seems like I'm clearly missing something. What's going on here?