This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
I think part of the disappointment is the lack of communication regarding violating the commitment or violating the expectations of a non-trivial fraction of the community.
If someone makes a promise to you or even sets an expectation for you in a softer way, there is of course always some chance that they will break the promise or violate the expectation.
But if they violate the commitment or the expectation, and they care about you as a stakeholder, I think there's a reasonable expectation that they should have to justify that decision.
If they break the promise or violate the soft expectation, and then they say basically nothing (or they say "well I never technically made a promise– there was no contract!", then I think you have the right to be upset with them not only for violating you expectation but also for essentially trying to gaslight you afterward.
I think a Responsible Lab would have issued some sort of statement along the lines of "hey, we're hearing that some folks thought we had made commitments to not advance the frontier and some of our employees were saying this to safety-focused members of the AI community. We're sorry about this miscommunication, and here are some steps we'll take to avoid such miscommunications in the future." or "We did in fact intend to follow-through on that, but here are some of the extreme events or external circumstances that caused us to change our mind."
In the absence of such statement, it makes it seem like Anthropic does not really care about honoring its commitments/expectations or generally defending its reasoning on important safety-relevant issues. I find it reasonable that this disposition harms Anthropic's reputation among safety-conscious people and makes safety-conscious people less excited about voluntary commitments from labs in general.