This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
You could be correct that takeover-capable AI will take longer than short timelines. You are definitely correct that there's a bit of groupthink going on around short timelines in the prosaic alignment and developer crowd.
But you could also easily be wrong. And you are entirely missing the fact that there's some groupthink going on around longer timelines in the agent foundations crowd.
Everyone is very tempted to sip a little hopium of some sort. The PA folks are hoping maybe alignment is so easy we can do it at a dead run. And the AF folks are hoping LLMs stall out just short of transformative so they have longer to work on alignment if it is, as they tend to believe, quite tricky.
So by all means lay plans for the eventuality of longer timelines and difficult alignment. But please don't go projecting confidence when we need to also prepare for short timelines.
You accuse short timeliners of making decisions based on an emotional stance. I think if you can look at this objectively you will see that your projection of longer timelines is also exactly that. You have reasons. But there are equally good reasons to expect fairly short timelines. The choice of beliefs comes down to preference. There are different merits to the positions that matter, but they aren't enough to confidently predict timelines or alignment difficulty.
The rational move is to say we don't know, and deal with that unfortunate situation as best we can.
I'm working on a more concise post on this point; for now the motivated reasoning post is my attempt to explain current unfortunate epistemic situation.