This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Rohin wouldn't have written his coherence theorems piece or any of his value learning sequence, and I'm pretty sure about that because I personally asked him to write that sequence
Yeah, that's true, though it might have happened at some later point in the future as I got increasingly frustrated by people continuing to cite VNM at me (though probably it would have been a blog post and not a full sequence).
Reading through this comment tree, I feel like there's a distinction to be made between "LW / AIAF as a platform that aggregates readership and provides better incentives for blogging", and "the intellectual progress caused by posts on LW / AIAF". The former seems like a clear and large positive of LW / AIAF, which I think Richard would agree with. For the latter, I tend to agree with Richard, though perhaps not as strongly as he does. Maybe I'd put it as, I only really expect intellectual progress from a few people who work on problems full time who probably would have done similar-ish work if not for LW / AIAF (but likely would not have made it public).
I'd say this mostly for the AI posts. I do read the rationality posts and don't get a different impression from them, but I also don't think enough about them to be confident in my opinions there.