To be honest, this post approaches a level of disjointedness from reality-as-I-understand-it that I fear I cannot accurately respond to it in a way that would satisfy the author.[1] However, if I don't give some response, I suspect that it will join a growing cultural current within LessWrong which involves an intellectualised rationalisation of ethnonationalism, hygiene-oriented eugenics, oligarchy[2], and implicit or explicit support of political action and political violence for these ends. If this current becomes normalised (and it has, frankly, always been present in the rationalist sphere), it makes TESCREAL-style categorisations of the rationalist/EA/AI safety intellectual sphere bascially correct. Therefore, I want to commit to voicing my objection to this line of argument where I see it. There are parts of me that feel strongly against doing this. There is no glory to be gained in political arguments online. However, there is the possibility of avoiding shame, which as a virtue ethicist I'm sure the author will understand.
On the question of inherent racial or ethnic attributes, I suspect that I will not be able to settle the argument "on the facts", given how long the online debate has been waged. Therefore I will cede as much as he wishes to stake "on the facts". Despite ceding this ground, I still maintain my fundamental belief that all human beings (and, increasingly I would argue, all life) are worthy of a deep and sincerely-held respect, regardless of any intellectual or physical discrepancies between them. This is not a utilitarian argument, but a deontological or virtue-oriented one, where the basis is one of universal love and compassion. No one should be deprived of a socially and physically healthy standard of living because of the circumstances of their birth or genetics. Nor are people's wants and needs more or less legitimate due to their intelligence, culture, belief or any other factor.
The arguments about inherent and unassailable differences between cultures presuppose what they aim to prove. They assert that, if culture is taken as an immutable, static prior that cannot be changed without being "diluted" or even "destroyed", that cultures from different parts of the world are incompatible. Well, yes, if you presuppose that change is death, then change cannot happen, or else death follows. This attitude goes against any reasonable study of the past and of human society. So many of the words and ideas that are powering this conversation and this forum: "culture", "virtue", "algorithm", even fundamental ideas like "zero" - are borrowed and integrated from other cultures. I will remind you again that it was not so long ago that, for example, French culture was considered utterly incompatible with or simply inferior to English culture, just as American culture was to British culture, as Polish culture was to American culture, or as Danish culture was to Swedish culture. So many differences that were once a matter of life and death quietly disappeared once the cultural battle lines shifted. We humans and all life forms in this universe are united by common world-models borne from within-lifetime observation of the world and bound by common laws of physics and information. Yes, shocks can happen from sudden changes in demographics. Yes, it is possible for tensions to arise and for relative needs between groups to be unmet, and therefore for conflict between groups to grow. But the missing mood is that of sorrow, because it is possible to do better. If it is not possible to do better...
The natural result of talk of immutable differences is life-or-death stakes. If they are different and irreconcilable to us, when we come into conflict with them we must destroy them, or otherwise secure some total strategic advantage. After all, this is game-theoretic conflict now, where we know that the outcome is explicitly zero-sum. Both parties cannot be convinced to cooperate and have incompatible terminal utility functions. The Nash equilibrium then is to defect.
And the longer they live and grow strong, the greater the threat is to us. For if in the future they secure some total strategic advantage, they would do the rational thing and wipe us out, seizing all future resources for themselves. I do not seek to exaggerate when I say that this is the argument that leads to final solutions and wars of hygiene. This is the Melian argument, brought to modern day geopolitics.
[...] and some treachery taking place inside, the Melians surrendered at discretion to the Athenians, who put to death all the grown men whom they took, and sold the women and children for slaves, and subsequently sent out five hundred colonists and inhabited the place themselves.
Thankfully, I believe that it is, in fact, possible to do better. That we have not found better coordination mechanisms is an engineering and social construction problem, not a problem of the failure to enact sufficiently powerful boundaries. Insofar as toxic egalitarianism and the managerial revolution have failed, their failures come from not understanding how to successfully coordinate under increasingly complex social and technical conditions, not from any inherent disdain of virtue or race to adopt increasingly ludicrous positions.
It is true, managing a global civilisation of 8.2 billion people is hard. But the author's "solutions" of ethnic segregation and socially-enforced virtue ethics enforced by inter-group mutual distrust come from historical societies where the effective politically-active population is measured (at most) in the thousands to hundreds of thousands, and those societies were all more or less self-sufficient and autarkic. For better or for worse, we live in a society with globally connected dependencies in matters of trade, manufacturing, business, and culture. Our scientific, technological, and medical progress is dependent on research and collaboration that stretches across borders. We are already deeply reliant on massive AI systems (incl. Google and Facebook) to manage our civilisational information throughput, and we are becoming more and more tightly integrated as supply chains lengthen and cross-cultural relationships deepen. At the same time, the threats we face of advanced AI systems, global thermonuclear war, pandemics, climate change etc. also do not confine themselves to a single society or region. There is no easy way back to the old system of walls and borders. In light of this I can see no good argument for bringing back the demons of the last century today.
For the most obvious example, for the life of me I cannot understand how leaving the gold standard makes a culture less appreciative of any kind of moral virtue, unless you equate two very different senses of the word "value".
E.g. under the name of e.g. "rule by the most qualified" and "rule by the most virtuous". The line of argument descends through Moldbug, who has since become more happy to openly support fascism and ad-hoc oligarchy under Trump post-2024.
[Footnote removed, I judged it to be overly combative and not constructive]