This is a special post for quick takes by Wei Dai. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
I think the main reason why UDT is not discussed in academia is that it is not a sufficiently rigorous proposal, as well as there not being a published paper on it. Hilary Greaves says the following in this 80k episode:
Then as many of your listeners will know, in the space of AI research, people have been throwing around terms like ‘functional decision theory’ and ‘timeless decision theory’ and ‘updateless decision theory’. I think it’s a lot less clear exactly what these putative alternatives are supposed to be. The literature on those kinds of decision theories hasn’t been written up with the level of precision and rigor that characterizes the discussion of causal and evidential decision theory. So it’s a little bit unclear, at least to my likes, whether there’s genuinely a competitor to decision theory on the table there, or just some intriguing ideas that might one day in the future lead to a rigorous alternative.
I also think it is unclear to what extent UDT and updateless are different from existing ideas in academia that are prima facie similar, like McClennen's (1990) resolute choice and Meacham's (2010, §4.2) cohesive decision theory.[1] Resolute choice in particular has been discussed in a lot of detail, and for a long time (see the citations of McClennen's book). (And, FWIW, my sense is that most philosophers think that resolute choice is irrational and/or doesn't make sense, at least if it is cashed out as a decision rule based on preference.)
It also doesn't help that it is unclear what the difference between FDT and UDT is supposed to be.
(If UDT is supposed to be an LDT of some sort, then you might want to check out Spohn's (2012)[2] version of CDT, Fisher's (n.d) disposition-based decision theory, and Poellinger's (2013) discussion of Spohn's theory, for ideas in academia that are similar to the LDT-part of the theory. And then there is also Schwarz' critique of FDT, which would then also apply to UDT, at least partially.)
My own take, using the terminology listed here, is that the causalist version of Meacham's cohesive decision theory is basically "updateless CDT", that the evidentialist version is basically "updateless EDT", and that a Spohn-CDT version of cohesive decision theory is basically "U(C)DT/F(C)DT". I also think that resolute choice is much more permissive than e.g. cohesive decision theory and updatelessness. As a decision rule, it doesn't recommend anything close to "maximizing EU relative to your prior". Instead, it just states that (i) what you prefer ex ante in a dynamic choice problem should be the same as you what you prefer in the normalised version of the problem, and (ii) you should be dynamically consistent (i.e., the most preferred plan should not change throughout the decision problem).